Vital Football

Latest Manchester City News

Time For Straight Talking From City

Time For Straight Talking From City

Google language translator

Manchester City FC now operates in a climate where the slightest indiscretion or issue will be blown out of all proportion. Time for club leadership and one voice...

Post the subterfuge, intrigue and unanswered questions that surrounded Kakagate, the sports hacks today leapt upon the fact that Robinho was no longer at City's FA Cup-less Tenerife training camp.

City Chairman Garry Cook found himself not only discussing Kakagate with the BBC this morning but also fending off questions over where our star player was. He declared 'I do know Robinho is not at the training centre in Tenerife. If he has left the training ground it is a breach of club discipline. I am waiting for a full debrief.'

Fast forward a few hours and Robinho announces that he is still happy at City and has flown to Brazil for family reasons.

'I had made Manchester City aware that I needed to return to Brazil because of a family matter.

'I will return to the club and hope to sort this out as soon as possible. I feel it is important to underline that I did not return to Brazil because of the Kaka deal.

'He is one of my good friends and it would have been great to see him at Manchester City - but it had nothing to do with his decision to stay in Milan.

'I am committed to helping Manchester City become the force the owners assured me they will become.'

So in one fell swoop, Cook revealed that as Executive Chairman he was not in full possession of the facts regarding Robinho and the players statement hints that there appears to be a communication problem surrounding the way the team operates off the park.

This obviously calls for a clear the air club statement so that Mark Hughes can get on with his efforts to pull the squad together.

If Cook and his team weren't fully aware of how European Football is run and it's situations manipulated then they will be now following the embarrassing Thaksin led pursuit of Ronaldhino last year and this month's dalliance with Kaka and AC Milan's manouevering. We could all see the Berlusconi shaped iceberg looming large this past weekend and yet it seems Cook and co didn't.

You got the impression City were never in control of the situation. The more I consider it there is a real element of naivety about City's decision to pursue Kaka this month, so early into the new owner's tenure. But both Cook and Mark Hughes promised surprises in January and with hindsight, they certainly shouldn't have.

This is now a time for regrouping and straight talking with lessons learned. The club need to make clear exactly what the situation is with Robinho and get into the practice of heading off developing mischief stories at the pass instead of playing catch up or allowing an unhealthy vacuum to develop the way it did throughout Sven-Goran Eriksson's agonising departure.

This is the time to start dictating events, City.


- When the first whistle blows, don't forget to join the Vital MC Community on our popular Live Match Thread in the Forums on match days.

Vital Manchester City is growing fast with now over 1,000 members and there's more to come - Be Here Now and join our worldwide community:

Writer:Johnny Baguette
Date:Tuesday January 20 2009
Time: 4:49PM


I agree JB, in your excellent article, that we have some naive people at the head of City in the board and this will be a hard lesson for them that the moral is do un to the others before the do unto you. In Cooks interview, he should have said that he had nothing to report to the Beeb at that time until he had spoken to the manager. Makes us look an amateur outfit and in propoganda we are.
Buzz Lightyear
20/01/2009 17:22:00
Spot on Johnny Baguette. Cook and Hughes are going to have to take the lessons of the Kaka debacle on board and get Europe savvy quick or they will get led astray again by other clubs.
20/01/2009 17:50:00
The way Berlusconi has been milking his new found popularity today has been sickening. Cook has been led a merry dance. probably couldn't have picked a worse club, who let's remember have played some garbage this season, to deal with for the second big transfer of the new regime.
Johnny Baguette
20/01/2009 17:54:00
It was all about politics in the end and you reasoned correctly JB Berlusconi had no intentions of selling Kaka, and made it such that he would look the hero in fending off this attack on their club by foreigners.
Buzz Lightyear
20/01/2009 18:04:00
I do work for Italians who are based in Rome from time to time and I can tell you, they can't be doing with him.
Johnny Baguette
20/01/2009 18:09:00
He's a hero, he must be up for election.
Buzz Lightyear
20/01/2009 18:15:00
I am sure that with time we will become a bit more savvy in the Market and test the water before jumping in. The owners want man city on the map, we are. The AC Milan spectacle has thrust us in the spotlight and if we want to come away with anything, let alone dignity in all of this, we should use this coverage as a leverage for persuading other players to join. "we want you to be our new kaka". We need a top signing if we are to live up to our promises, forget Milan politics.
20/01/2009 18:55:00
Absolutely, eighth. I think the club should go one further however and underline what Cook said about City not putting money on the table. After all, it was Berlusconi who announced a price and salary, nobody else. I just hope that other clubs don't start demanding £100 million for every player we show interest in!!!
Johnny Baguette
20/01/2009 19:00:00
Hindsight is a wonderful thing isn't it. Last week I didn't see Berlusconi messing us about, all I saw was my club offering a ridiculous amount of money for a hugely talented player (when it really needed to be spent elsewhere in the team). Whilst my head didn't want Kaka my heart went a bit wobbly with the sheer madness of it all. But ever since the summer (and before that with the dreadful Thaksin) we've been blinded by the money. It's always 'the money', always about who we're going to buy rather than developing what we already have. It's just become Spend Spend Spend, a medium sized club that has become a rich mans plaything/PR indulgence. Now everyone (be they in Britain or abroad) will see and hear us coming and it's they, not us who will decide how our cloth will be cut. Until we learn to say no and mean it then we will continue to dance to others tunes. We walked away from the Kaka deal (apparently) but it's a pity we didn't show that kind of single mindedness with Be££amy. Maybe I imagined it but didn't MH say we weren't going to pay over the odds for players? yeah, right...
20/01/2009 19:06:00
Good call Kenny. I don't recall Chelski or the rags ever being pilloried in public to the extent City have when they repeatedly broke the transfer records. It's almost as if there is a campaign for City are to be stopped at all costs from daring to even consider becoming successful. Winning a trophy looks like an absolute mountain to climb right now.
Johnny Baguette
20/01/2009 19:13:00
Page 1/2
  1. 1
  2. 2

Login to post a comment

Recent Manchester City Articles

Manchester City Injury Worries Clearing

Our weekly update looking at the injury table for Manchester City and also comparing with all our competitors in the Premier League.

The Ped intoEurope Report City 1-0 Feyenoord

Not Quite a Cruise for the Blues

Manchester City Duo In Team Of The Week (23/11/17)

Manchester City are represented in the latest Premier League team of the week that has been selected by BBC pundit Garth Crooks.

Stats: Manchester City v Feyenoord

All the stats from Manchester City (1) vs (0) Feyenoord, The Etihad Stadium, 21/11/17 19h45 GMT Att: 43,548

Archived VMC Articles

VMC articles from

Site Journalists

Editor email
Johnny Baguette
no email
no email
no email

Current Poll (see more polls)

Should City Go Full Strength In The Ukraine Before The Stretfords?
Suggested By: Brian Horton
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites
Write for Vital Football
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
The Vital Football Members League

Recent Manchester City Results (view all)

Manchester City Fixtures (view all)

Vital Members League Table

1.Buzz Lightyear497
2.Johnny Baguette229
5.Colin Is The King142
Vital Football Comment