UK time is: 09:23:37
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

Do City Need An Experienced Keeper?

Google language translator


City has been heavily linked with several goalkeepers in recent weeks but the question is, do we really need another keeper?

With Joe Hart and Kasper Schmeichel coming through and showing their vast potential, would it benefit City to sign another goalkeeper while sending Joe and Kasper down the pecking order?

Some people would argue that we definitely need a new shot-stopper, perhaps in an effort to pass on their experience to our young goalies, but surely experience comes from playing matches, and signing another goalkeeper would heavily decrease Hart's playtime and possibly shut the door on Schmeichel's future City career.

Although there are always two sides to a story, and many others believe that for a young keeper to really show their potential they need an already experienced keeper to act as a mentor and nurture their talent.

If Manchester City is to sign another keeper (though they will have to look fast as time is running out, what with Kinnear keen to hold on to his star man Shay Given, and other City target Carlo Cudicini signing for Tottenham earlier today, plus a supposed big money bid being rejected for Iker Casillias), there isn't too much to choose from.

So who should Manchester City approach? Maybe an increased bid for Given would make Kinnear re-think his decision, or perhaps a record bid for Italian shot-stopper Buffon might do the trick.

Who know, but with only seven days left until the transfer window closes; Mark Hughes and his team had better get their skates on.

Many thanks go out to 'warmouths' for submitting this article.



The journalist

Writer: Tudor Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Monday January 26 2009

Time: 8:45PM

Your Comments (oldest first)

Change to most recent first
yes
swordfish7
Report Abuse
26/01/2009 21:04:00

we definately need another one as kasper wants to move to secure first team football. It's a shame cudicini went to tottenham as I feel he is good enough to battle hart for no.1 spot but not good enough to push hart onto the bench permenantly - which is what I expect would happen with given.
eighthsin
Report Abuse
26/01/2009 21:06:00

I don't think signing a goalkeeper should be our top priority in this window. We seem to have got the players in to shore up our defense which in turn should put less pressure on the 'keeper thereby giving him better confidence. Maybe in the summer bring in an older 'keeper for a couple of years one who will not be to fussed about sitting on the bench.
alphieblues
Report Abuse
26/01/2009 21:06:00

If all the hype and the rumours are true, then nothing can be done about Given until Thursday, the day after they play us. They're going to need him against the second most potent striking force in the league.
roy harper
Report Abuse
26/01/2009 21:09:00

Ye if were going to get Given we should move quick so he can't play wednesday I think Kinnear knows he is going to sell him as he has just give Steve Harper their number 2 a new deal an they have been linked with a move for David james.
watmoughst
Report Abuse
26/01/2009 21:12:00

Def need an experienced keeper, Hart is a great young keeper and can only get better. But i think we could do ith a keeper that has a Presence.. i think this comes with time eg.Given,Cech,James,Freidel,Van d Sar etc. All the above are in their 30s and as a keeper i def think this experience shows. GO GET GIVEN BOYS
belfastblue
Report Abuse
26/01/2009 22:18:00

Yes, someone to provide competition for the shirt is vital. People worry about Jo Hart's development suffering if he doesn't play games; It will suffer even more if he becomes complacent in thinking he's automatic first choice. I would have preferred Cudicini, as he would have been a slightly shorter term solution, but Given is a very good keeper, and Jo Hart will have to work to retain his place. Ultimately I can see Hart keeping Given on the bench!
fifthcolumnblue
Report Abuse
26/01/2009 23:12:00

I think we should get a keeper, for me , though I like him a lot, Hart seems to have something missing and Alphie I think you have got it right that he has too much pressure on him at the moment with our not so solid defence . Given is good and I would get him whatever it takes. I would let Kasper go as I don't think he is quite good enough at the moment for the premier league but I'm sure that one day he will be, maybe we could loan him out for a season or two so he can get the first team football he craves maybe in the championship. The only problem I see is how do you rotate goalkeepers?
romancity
Report Abuse
26/01/2009 23:13:00

Heard from someone who works at the BUPA hospital in Whalley Range that Given had his medical there today. Expect the deal to be delayed so he can't play against the barcodes on Wednesday.
pottsy
Report Abuse
26/01/2009 23:38:00

perfect signing for a keeper....still good enough to be a top prem keeper....but also proffessional enough to know that Hart needs games to improve his already excellent potential. Would be the best possible mentor Hart could ever hope for.....
lincolnblue
Report Abuse
27/01/2009 07:51:00

RH & Pottsy are both right in that to play Given in Wednesdays match would not go down well with the barcodes and you cannot write into a transfer that a player can or cannot play against his old team. If the medical thing is true, then I expect Shay Given to be registered just too late to play for the blues tonight. The difference bewteen Hart and Given is that Given will organise the defense better than Hart as he is a veteran keeper, Hart will learn from this, but I hope that Hart does not throw his teddy out of the cot if Given does sign, but make him more determined. If City are going to purchase players they will want the best in every position and Hart will grow with this experience of having a much senior goalkeeper in the team.
Buzz Lightyear
Report Abuse
27/01/2009 08:09:00

All competition is healthy, and to challenge the big four you have to have world class in every position, the goalkeeping position is just as important. If Hart does through his toys then he can join the rest of them on the transfer list at the end of the season, I only want players fully commited to the cause like Danny Mills.....(joke)
purple ninja
Report Abuse
27/01/2009 09:51:00

Afternoon Citizens. Here's the latest look at things from the NUFC side of the fence: http://www.newcastle.vitalfootball.co.uk/article.asp?a=140973
BaldEagle
Report Abuse
27/01/2009 14:31:00

It has been said that neither City or Newcastle want to negotiate a deal for Given before Wednesdays game but it does look likely that we will sign him, im really lookin forward to 2nd february hopefully City will make a shock signing again and at least this time the window closes at 17.00GMT so i dont have to stay up refreshing skysports till 12.00.
watmoughst
Report Abuse
27/01/2009 18:11:00

 

Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Manchester City Articles

Mangala - I'm Still Adapting (Thursday January 29 2015)

Sinclair To Villa Back On (Thursday January 29 2015)

Clash Of The Titans (Thursday January 29 2015)

Down To Fate? (Tuesday January 27 2015)

Inter Play Down Yaya Rumours (Sunday January 25 2015)

Pellegrini - We Have No FA Cup Excuse (Saturday January 24 2015)

Stats: Manchester City v Middlesbrough (Saturday January 24 2015)

No Villa Move For Scott (Saturday January 24 2015)

Team News - City v Middlesbrough (Friday January 23 2015)

Archived Manchester City Articles

List All VMC Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

1. Buzz Lightyear 441
2. Johnny Baguette 354
3. Skoorb 320
4. fifthcolumnblue 261
5. Bluedub 255
6. kennyclementstache 228
7. citizhun 211
8. rojo2010 191
9. CITYBOY1000 124
10. Chippy_Tea 105

League Results (view all)

Latest Results
Man City 0 - 2 Arsenal
Everton 1 - 1 Man City
Man City 3 - 2 Sunderland
Man City 2 - 2 Burnley
WBA 1 - 3 Man City
Man City 3 - 0 Crystal Palace

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
1. Chelsea 22 16 4 2 +32 52
2. Man City 22 14 5 3 +23 47
3. Southampton 22 13 3 6 +21 42
4. Man Utd 22 11 7 4 +15 40
5. Arsenal 22 11 6 5 +14 39
6. Spurs 22 11 4 7 +2 37
7. West Ham 22 10 6 6 +10 36

Breaking League News

Everton offer Real Madrid a deal
Everton : 30/01/2015 09:20:00
Departure Lounge!
Spurs : 30/01/2015 08:54:00
Warnock - If Only I Was Sacked Sooner
Crystal Palace : 30/01/2015 08:30:00
Huth to join Foxes?
Stoke : 30/01/2015 05:02:00
Swansea City Agree Fee For Southampton's Cork
Swansea : 29/01/2015 20:01:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Chelsea v City
Suggested By:  
City win 34%
Chelsea win 16%
Draw 50%