UK time is: 01:39:38
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

The VCZ: City Progress Or Flatter To Deceive?



THE VITAL CITY ZEN

CITY PROGRESS OR FLATTER TO DECEIVE?

City are through to the UEFA Cup Quarter Finals but have the side truly progressed in the second half of this gruelling season? Appalling away performances suggest they haven't...

I'd say that the City fans 'No' Camp looks to be edging out the 'Yes' camp right now as we brace ourselves for a season defining fortnight.

On paper or on computer, City have successfully reached the Quarter Finals of the UEFA Cup and have just about stabilised a league position that was in danger of settling in the relegation zone thanks to home wins alone. Mark Hughes stated prior to the drudgery of the Arsenal performance that a seventh placed league finish remains his objective.

But...it has taken an unprecedented January outlay to bring us to this point.

Were it not for Shay Given's heroics at Aalborg, City would be out of the UEFA Cup by now and knee knacked Craig Bellamy's goals have helped to ensure we have kept a safe enough distance from the Premier League drop zone.

But the side have continued to put in poor performances on the road across both competitions save for the 1-1 draw at Liverpool and the 2-2 draw in Copenhagen. Both games that they could have and should have won had they continued to take the game to their opponents instead of retreating into containment tactics that this team simply cannot maintain.

Hughes promised us that his sides always put in strong second halves to seasons and we were led to believe that his City squad would be fitter and fighters. You can't help but beg to differ when you consider City's last two tired league performances against Sunderland post Aalborg and Arsenal post international break.

Once again, the squad is suffering a surfeit of injuries prior to this week's crunch Euro clash in Hamburg which was precisely the case in Schalke last November. Thigh, hamstring and calf strains re-occur with alarming regularity and very often it is admitted that the injuries were picked up in training. When you factor in new signing Nigel De Jong and Bellamy's history of injury concerns the treatment room at SportCity must be issuing 'wait to be served' tickets.

As many of us bemoaned before Christmas, we expected that Hughes, a notorious hard man in his playing days would bring a siege mentality to Eastlands but there hasn't been a whiff of it. That fact is backed up by the side's seeming inability or reluctance to get stuck in and chase the opposition around the park, particularly on the road. City's travelling faithful deserve to see tackles made and their side at least let the opposition know they are in a game.

Hughes even admitted after the Arsenal game that The Gooners were more athletic than The Blues.

To all intents and purposes, our season is at a crossroads now. Seven league games including some nasty away fixtures remain, and of course there is the small matter of Hamburg to overcome if we are to reach the UEFA Cup semi-finals.

The season has been unprecedented for modern day City sides in it's length and intensity and at the same time has been an extraordinary rollercoaster ride where one week we experience a feel good factor which is promptly replaced by concern and disappointment the following week.

Shaun Wright-Phillips, who alongside Stephen Ireland has been easily City's most committed player this season and who recently told Vital MC that he saw this season very much as a work in progress reckons that Hughes and his backroom staff will ensure City kick on next season once they have had a year with the squad.

But back to the present and the fact is that for City to reach the final of the UEFA Cup and/ or finish in seventh place in the Premier League, then the side will have to find levels of fitness, commitment and consistency that have so far eluded them throughout the season.

Inside four weeks we will either be buzzing or crestfallen. Based on our experiences this long season, there'll be no middle ground having been through so much.

We need Mark Hughes to be a success at City and for our club to find managerial stability now we have remained in the top flight for seven years and have top drawer owner's at the controls.

Regardless of upcoming results I for one will be prepared to forgive a fair number of grievances this season if the City 'project' starts to show some real fight and endeavour in the coming weeks and the promised improvement becomes reality with some back to back wins.

But hand on heart, based on what has gone before, right now I can't see it happening as the frustration of watching the side swing from positivity to confused caution threatens to continue.

Of course, this wouldn't be Manchester City if our side didn't deliver the unexpected, but for me our league and cup positions flatter to deceive.

Prove me wrong, City!

- Agree or disagree? Give us your thoughts both here and in the Vital MC Forum.

WHAT'S IN A WORD? THIS WEEK'S QUOTES

'We just lacked a bit of physical presence to dictate to the opposition. They are a big athletic side who are able to get around the pitch. As the game wore on, we found it more and more difficult in that respect...I just sensed that we lacked a little bit of presence on the field to enable us to ask a good Arsenal side enough questions from 1-0 down.'

- Mark Hughes reflects upon another lacklustre City showing in London.

'He's played games in the Premier League now and acquitted himself really well, so he can play at a high level. His international career will supplement his career here and help his development as well...Obviously it's better if he's in a winning team - it can be a bit soul-destroying if you are in a group of young players not getting positive results. But looking at the crop coming through, hopefully things will change.'

- Hughesy goes on to suggest that Chedwyn Evans could be the answer to Wales' attacking shortcomings. Not sure about that one at all, MH.

'Strikers like Jo need time and confidence. If you look at players from South America, they are slow starters when they come here. Carlos Tevez did not begin well when he first came to England and nor did Javier Mascherano. But I can understand why Manchester City loaned him out because in January they had a surfeit of strikers and we had none.'

- Shrewd cookie David Moyes, benefitting from his careful handling of a previously pisspoor Jo hints again that his Everton loan move might become a permanent one.

'I know about rumours linking me with different teams but I am not pre-occupied by them. My head only has time for City and I want to be the star of this club. I am totally convinced City can win the UEFA Cup. A title in my first season in England will be magnificent. City are preparing an enormous project for next season and I am totally focused on this adventure. We could really be big in the table in a few months.'

- For all the knocking and speculation that surrounds him, Robinho has never once talked the club down in interviews and maintained his stance before the Arsenal game that he is in it for the long haul.

'I definitely think it's only a matter of time before City are really challenging for things. We need more consistency but once we get that, we will put a lot of teams on the back foot and under the cosh. We are on a great run in the UEFA Cup and next year when all the team is bedded in more we'll definitely kick on. There have been a lot of new faces but once everyone's settled in I think we'll be fine when we get that consistency, especially away from home. I believe that, with the players who may come in the summer as well, we have a great chance to battle for everything next year.'

- Shaun Wright-Phillips is only looking in one direction and that's forward with positivity.


WE WEREN'T REALLY THERE? THE FINAL SCORE THIS WEEK 10 YEARS AGO

Football League Division One
Maine Road, 10th April 1999

CITY 4 (2) - 0 (0) Lincoln

Scorers: Dickov, 34, 45, 48 Horlock 63

City: Weaver, Crooks, Tiatto, Vaughan, Morrison, Horlock, Brown, Bishop (Whitley,82 ), Dickov (Robins, 72), Goater (Gareth Taylor,65), Cooke

Attendance: 26, 298

NEXT OPPONENTS:

Hamburg Sport-Verein
@ The Hamburg Arena

UEFA Cup Quarter Final First Leg
Thursday 9th April 2009 @ 19:45 GMT+1 BST

The Citizens Last 6 UEFA Cup games: DLDWWL
Hamburg Last 6 UEFA Cup games: WWWWDW

Internet:

www.hsv.de/index.php?id=9431 (Official site in English)

http://www.hsv-sc.de/typo3/ (Supporters Club)

Vital MC is in the process of arranging a UEFA Magnificent Seven Fans Q&A with Hamburg's Supporters Club before the game.

Johnny On The Spot?

When you put City and Hamburg's UEFA Cup form and results head to head, on paper this will be no contest with Hamburg going through to the semi finals with relative ease. They've cruised past some teams and pulled off a potentially campaign defining win by coming back from the dead in the Galatasaray cauldron to reach the quarter finals. They also have a tremendous team spirit and work ethic which was underlined in the way their 10 man side celebrated after their 1-0 win over Hoffenheim at the weekend.

City meanwhile have stuttered along in Europe somewhat, doing just enough to progress. But City have defied the odds in Germany already this season. Mark Hughes took all the available 18 fit senior players he had at his disposal to Schalke in November and the team put in one of the performances of the season.

I'm ambitiously, perhaps insanely banking on that same European spirit to see us through as long as the muscle strains and tear injuries that Hughes' City squad pick up with regularity are overcome in the main. It won't be at all easy, but some of City's results in this competition are classic examples of a team's name being on the cup.

Hamburg 0 CITY 2

NEXT OPPONENTS BUT ONE:

Fulham
@ The City of Manchester Stadium

FA Premier League
Sunday 12th April 2009 @ 16:10 GMT+1 BST

The Citizens Last 6 PL games: DLWLWL
Fulham Last 6 PL games: DLLLWL

Internet:

www.fulham.vitalfootball.co.uk

www.fulhamfc.com

Vital MC aims to bring you our Magnificent Seven Fans Q&A with Vital Fulham before the game.

Johnny On The Spot?

Fulham, to their credit have done their very best to upset The Big Four's respective apple carts this year but their otherwise Cityesque erratic form sees them stumbling along with us in this season's mid table UEFA chasing/ relegation avoiding lottery. Roy Hodgson is a shrewd operator and as we saw at Eastlands last April and at Craven Cottage in December has instilled something of a never say die attitude into his side.

That said, City are imperious at home and when turgid away form and tough remaining fixtures are taken into account, need to win this game to have any chance of UEFA qualification via the league.

Thursday's events in Hamburg will almost certainly have an impact. This City team tend to tire worryingly in games post UEFA flights. But we should have enough in the tank to keep the faint seventh place flame flickering.

CITY 2 Fulham 1

JOIN VITAL MANCHESTER CITY:

When the first whistle blows, don't forget to join the Vital MC Community on our popular Live Match Thread in the Forums on match days.

Vital Manchester City and it's Forums are growing fast with over 1,200 Blues now registered with us. There's more to come - Be Here Now and join our worldwide community:



The journalist

Writer: Johnny Baguette Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Monday April 6 2009

Time: 3:02AM

Your Comments

Great read as always JB, have to agree its testing times at City. Really struggling to get any positives out of our performances this season- save a few impressive home wins and UEFA Cup progress. If we win against Hamburg then I think we can finish strongly, a loss would make the whole season a disappointment. Im backing Hughes and the majority of players and I really hope that they prove me right!
eighthsin
Great read as always JB, have to agree its testing times at City. Really struggling to get any positives out of our performances this season- save a few impressive home wins and UEFA Cup progress. If we win against Hamburg then I think we can finish strongly, a loss would make the whole season a disappointment. Im backing Hughes and the majority of players and I really hope that they prove me right!
eighthsin
Bottom line is Hughes has to go. All he proves week in and week out is how out of his depth he is at a club the size of City.
derry
Bottom line is Hughes has to go. All he proves week in and week out is how out of his depth he is at a club the size of City.
derry
Super article as we have come to expect from you JB ....but I think it gets back to my old hobby horse the lack of depth (quality) we have in our squad
Doody
Super article as we have come to expect from you JB ....but I think it gets back to my old hobby horse the lack of depth (quality) we have in our squad
Doody
ok you asked for what i think so its not my fault lol
bluemooner_mcfc
to be honest we havent moved forward all season as far as im concerned and thats even with the "is sven being sacked...isnt sven being sacked" form before last christmas. with all that going on with sven you had to expect us to dip in form and players not giving 100% but this is different this season as we had the world at our feet to do well with a new respected manager who was supposed to be good at fitness and dicipline and hes come to city and as far as i can see not made that much of a difference. his best performers so far this season have been ned,ireland,richards(2nd half of the season),elano looking better,bojinov and dunne is settling down better with ned at the side of him. all of the above players are either svens signings or youth players that have come through(apart from dunne) and then we have swp,given who have been fantastic and then we have robbie who plays well at home and we need the nouse to get him playing well away which i cant under our current system we play. im not hughes bashing here but all im saying is we was told by our manager that "WATCH US GO IN THE SECOND HALF OF THE SEASON" and im still watching us and cant see us go. some might say but we are in the quarter finals of the uefa cup.....BIG DEAL we have had lots and lots of luck getting this far with 2 penalty shoot outs and we could have gone out in the qualifiers in truth. so where does that leave us then?? for me im giving hughes my backing until the end of the season and then im quite sure we will know either way if he truely is the right man for our club but i will say something else which is this.... we have played terrible against chelsea,manyoo,arsenal(last game),liverpool at our place and we crumbbled at anfield after they scored,villa away,everton at home and we will at goodison,we have struggled against bolton,wigan,boro(both games),we was lucky against hull away to get a point and thats to name a few. i know my thoughts about why we have done so badly especially away from home but the question is......what do you think??
bluemooner_mcfc
ok you asked for what i think so its not my fault lol
bluemooner_mcfc
to be honest we havent moved forward all season as far as im concerned and thats even with the "is sven being sacked...isnt sven being sacked" form before last christmas. with all that going on with sven you had to expect us to dip in form and players not giving 100% but this is different this season as we had the world at our feet to do well with a new respected manager who was supposed to be good at fitness and dicipline and hes come to city and as far as i can see not made that much of a difference. his best performers so far this season have been ned,ireland,richards(2nd half of the season),elano looking better,bojinov and dunne is settling down better with ned at the side of him. all of the above players are either svens signings or youth players that have come through(apart from dunne) and then we have swp,given who have been fantastic and then we have robbie who plays well at home and we need the nouse to get him playing well away which i cant under our current system we play. im not hughes bashing here but all im saying is we was told by our manager that "WATCH US GO IN THE SECOND HALF OF THE SEASON" and im still watching us and cant see us go. some might say but we are in the quarter finals of the uefa cup.....BIG DEAL we have had lots and lots of luck getting this far with 2 penalty shoot outs and we could have gone out in the qualifiers in truth. so where does that leave us then?? for me im giving hughes my backing until the end of the season and then im quite sure we will know either way if he truely is the right man for our club but i will say something else which is this.... we have played terrible against chelsea,manyoo,arsenal(last game),liverpool at our place and we crumbbled at anfield after they scored,villa away,everton at home and we will at goodison,we have struggled against bolton,wigan,boro(both games),we was lucky against hull away to get a point and thats to name a few. i know my thoughts about why we have done so badly especially away from home but the question is......what do you think??
bluemooner_mcfc
 

Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Articles

The Ped Report City 2-2 Sunderland (Thursday April 17 2014)

Stats: Manchester City v Sunderland (Wednesday April 16 2014)

The Citizens versus The Black Cats (Wednesday April 16 2014)

The Ped Report Liverpool 3-2 City (Sunday April 13 2014)

The Reds versus The Citizens (Saturday April 12 2014)

Archived Articles

List All VMC Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

1. Johnny Baguette 288
2. Skoorb 150
3. Buzz Lightyear 119
4. PhillyBlueMoon 115
5. rojo2010 101
6. fifthcolumnblue 101
7. Bluedub 91
8. kennyclementstache 88
9. Spooks 87
10. citizhun 86

League Results (view all)

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
1. Liverpool 35 25 5 5 +52 80
2. Chelsea 35 23 6 6 +41 75
3. Man City 33 22 5 6 +54 71
4. Arsenal 35 21 7 7 +21 70
5. Everton 35 20 9 6 +23 69
6. Spurs 35 19 6 10 +2 63
7. Man Utd 34 17 6 11 +16 57

Breaking League News

Ashamed of Newcastle United
Newcastle : 20/04/2014 20:48:00
Vital Report: Cardiff 1 Stoke 1
Cardiff : 20/04/2014 18:54:00
United - No Cutting Edge!
Man Utd : 20/04/2014 18:46:00
Man Utd : 20/04/2014 18:39:00
Everton : 20/04/2014 18:12:00
Dear Randy...A Fans Retort
Aston Villa : 20/04/2014 17:36:00
City Defeated In Five Goal Thriller
Norwich : 20/04/2014 17:04:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Yaya Injured - Who Should Partner Fernandinho In Midfield?
Suggested By:  Gerry Gow
Javi Garcia 25%
Jimmy Milner 75%