UK time is: 10:22:55
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

PFA Award: Stephen Ireland v Ashley Young

From the comparison below from their latest games you can see the difference between the two players quite clearly.

Stephen Ireland has a much higher pass completion rate, as well as working all over the pitch to help his team.

The evidence in favour of Ireland is overwhelming and the fact that the Manchester City midfielder did not claim the coveted award only serves to diminish the credibility of the FA.

















In addition to this, the fact that Rio Ferdinand was nominated ahead of Brede Hangeland and Ryan Giggs was nominated ahead of Frank Lampard makes the whole awards a farce.

The fact that 12 games and a solitary goal Giggs actually won the main award is beggars belief.




Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!



For the very latest Premier League odds

For massive weekly jackpots - Play the Football Pools Online




Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

The journalist

Writer: Lincolnsmariner Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Tuesday April 28 2009

Time: 3:47AM

Your Comments

I think this article says it all - the FA and the rest of the PL are against City and our players. I would think SI would have walked it if the neutral fan had voted.
Thaibluefan
I think this article says it all - the FA and the rest of the PL are against City and our players. I would think SI would have walked it if the neutral fan had voted.
Thaibluefan
I was astounded that young won it, i personally thought it was between Ireland and Lennon.
Yid_from_India
I was astounded that young won it, i personally thought it was between Ireland and Lennon.
Yid_from_India
Thanks Yid ...why don't you join us in the forums from time to time ....I have often thought there was no justice in this world and this goes a long way to proving it .....not worth much Stevie but you are MY player of the year
Doody
Thanks Yid ...why don't you join us in the forums from time to time ....I have often thought there was no justice in this world and this goes a long way to proving it .....not worth much Stevie but you are MY player of the year
Doody
Your quote that "the fact that the Manchester City midfielder did not claim the coveted award only serves to diminish the credibility of the FA" only goes to diminish YOUR credibility! The award is from the PFA - Professional Footballers Association - NOT the FA. It is voted for by professional footballers. I know City fans can be paranoid, but get real!
mcfc2112
Your quote that "the fact that the Manchester City midfielder did not claim the coveted award only serves to diminish the credibility of the FA" only goes to diminish YOUR credibility! The award is from the PFA - Professional Footballers Association - NOT the FA. It is voted for by professional footballers. I know City fans can be paranoid, but get real!
mcfc2112
mcfc2112....theres no need for an attack on the article poster mate as us REGUALRS on here are very very passionate about everything about city and you might see that if you joined us from time to time...anyway back to the article....stevie should have won it and its not just city fans who think that its also most of the national press and also how can giggs win it with only 12 games played? i know it goes aoff a calender year but hes not been that good for well over a year. and look at the PFA team of the year..are you telling me thats right aswell??
bluemooner_mcfc
mcfc2112....theres no need for an attack on the article poster mate as us REGUALRS on here are very very passionate about everything about city and you might see that if you joined us from time to time...anyway back to the article....stevie should have won it and its not just city fans who think that its also most of the national press and also how can giggs win it with only 12 games played? i know it goes aoff a calender year but hes not been that good for well over a year. and look at the PFA team of the year..are you telling me thats right aswell??
bluemooner_mcfc
You only need to look at the full season stats. How many goals for SI how many for AY? How many assists, etc etc. No contest the votes are cast in Feb and that's stupid.
jackblue
It may or may not demonstrate bias against MCFC: One thing it clearly does demonstrate is bias TOWARDS teams at the top of the premiership. Villa were flying high before January (when I believe the votes were cast) and were on course for a Champions League berth, so Young will have caught everyone's eye. Unfortunately for Steven Ireland (or anyone else playing for a lower placed team), the sheeple that are modern footballers are like simpletons drawn to shiny things (just like most rags fans!), so I guess that there was very little chance of him winning the award. If the voting had been later I suspect Young may not have even received a nomination, such has been Villa's freefall in the league. On another note, I do think that the only reason Giggs received the award was as a sympathy vote for a player who is more than likely heading for retirement in the summer. It certainly wasn't based on his contribution to United or the game in general!!!
fifthcolumnblue
You only need to look at the full season stats. How many goals for SI how many for AY? How many assists, etc etc. No contest the votes are cast in Feb and that's stupid.
jackblue
It may or may not demonstrate bias against MCFC: One thing it clearly does demonstrate is bias TOWARDS teams at the top of the premiership. Villa were flying high before January (when I believe the votes were cast) and were on course for a Champions League berth, so Young will have caught everyone's eye. Unfortunately for Steven Ireland (or anyone else playing for a lower placed team), the sheeple that are modern footballers are like simpletons drawn to shiny things (just like most rags fans!), so I guess that there was very little chance of him winning the award. If the voting had been later I suspect Young may not have even received a nomination, such has been Villa's freefall in the league. On another note, I do think that the only reason Giggs received the award was as a sympathy vote for a player who is more than likely heading for retirement in the summer. It certainly wasn't based on his contribution to United or the game in general!!!
fifthcolumnblue
as much as i think that Ireland deserved it,the stats above is non-sence. It is based on one game and more over asley young is a winger and hence crosses a lot more than Ireland,it is very rarely that crosses reach its desired target and hence will have more mis placed passes.
Yid_from_India
as much as i think that Ireland deserved it,the stats above is non-sence. It is based on one game and more over asley young is a winger and hence crosses a lot more than Ireland,it is very rarely that crosses reach its desired target and hence will have more mis placed passes.
Yid_from_India
I thought it was between Young and Ireland, I'd have had no arguments either way but only one could win and they do look at more than just pass completions, they look at the impact on the team etc. Awards are always open to questionning I guess but I think Ash is every bit as deserving of the recognition as Ireland would have been. Both smashing players.
The Fear
I thought it was between Young and Ireland, I'd have had no arguments either way but only one could win and they do look at more than just pass completions, they look at the impact on the team etc. Awards are always open to questionning I guess but I think Ash is every bit as deserving of the recognition as Ireland would have been. Both smashing players.
The Fear
Yeah got to agree,the awards this season were a farce,how Giggs won is beyond me,it is the "player of the year",not the "you've had a great career" award.I would have put my house on Ireland winning young player,hopefully he'll get the recognition from the football writers.
CoxintheBox
Yeah got to agree,the awards this season were a farce,how Giggs won is beyond me,it is the "player of the year",not the "you've had a great career" award.I would have put my house on Ireland winning young player,hopefully he'll get the recognition from the football writers.
CoxintheBox
Hope Giggs has the grace to realise he's been awarded the sentimental vote from fellow players. It's not a lifetime achievement award for *****s sake. (Which i wouldn't hold against him actually). JOKE.
RobsonGreensleeves
Hope Giggs has the grace to realise he's been awarded the sentimental vote from fellow players. It's not a lifetime achievement award for *****s sake. (Which i wouldn't hold against him actually). JOKE.
RobsonGreensleeves
 

Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Manchester City Articles

Kompany Boost For City (Thursday November 20 2014)

Fernando Expects Chelsea Slip (Wednesday November 19 2014)

Frustrated Sinclair Just Wants To Play (Wednesday November 19 2014)

French Interest In Guidetti? (Wednesday November 19 2014)

Nastasic Out, Messi In? (Tuesday November 18 2014)

Hart Break (Sunday November 16 2014)

Calf Injury Worry For Kompany (Tuesday November 11 2014)

Arsenal & Chelsea Selected For TV (Tuesday November 11 2014)

Pellegrini 'Under Review' Next Summer (Tuesday November 11 2014)

Dzeko Out For Three Weeks (Monday November 10 2014)

Archived Manchester City Articles

List All VMC Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

League Results (view all)

Latest Results
Q.P.R. 2 - 2 Man City
Man City 1 - 0 Man Utd
West Ham 2 - 1 Man City
Man City 4 - 1 Spurs
Aston Villa 0 - 2 Man City
Hull City 2 - 4 Man City

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
1. Chelsea 11 9 2 0 +17 29
2. Southampton 11 8 1 2 +18 25
3. Man City 11 6 3 2 +10 21
4. West Ham 11 5 3 3 +5 18
5. Swansea 11 5 3 3 +4 18
6. Arsenal 11 4 5 2 +6 17
7. Man Utd 11 4 4 3 +3 16

Breaking League News

Score for Us?
» Man Utd : 21/11/2014 10:18:00
That Winter Break Conundrum!
» West Ham : 21/11/2014 10:15:00
Stones pleased with rehabilitation
» Everton : 21/11/2014 10:00:00
No January raid on Wolfsburg
» Everton : 21/11/2014 09:06:00
Aston Villa FC - 140 Years And Counting
» Aston Villa : 21/11/2014 09:05:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Your Favourite Kun Goal From The QPR Horror Show?
Suggested By:  The Headshaker Ritual
Agüero 32′ 50%
Agüero 83′ 50%