Vital Football

Latest Manchester City News

Would You Change Any Football Rules / Laws?

Would You Change Any Football Rules / Laws?


Vital Manchester City stalwart, Buzz Lightyear posted the following via our Off Topic forum.

I was thinking the other day, that it has always been unfair when a player goes down injured that he should go off and not come on a again until the play has restarted.

If the player is fouled, then surely the team that was fouled should have an advantage i.e. a free kick, but already the player has to leave the field, should not the player who committed the foul leave the field?

The offside law continually seems to baffle me. Assistant linesmen don't put their flags up until the player offside touches the ball and then you get situations where they put the flag up anyway. Does this law need to be clarified one way or the other, should offside mean offside?

They talk about interfering with play, but if a shot comes in from 20 yards and a striker is in front of goal surely that is interference?

Booking, in the days gone past it was rare for a booking never mind a sending off and now they are common place, should a player be sent off after receiving two yellow cards one for a foul and one for celebrating a goal by taking his shirt off?

Could they not introduce a system for minor infringements, that players are sent to a sin bin for 10 minutes?

If you take a look at corner kicks referees insist that the ball is touching the line before they can take the kick, but in determining whether a goal is scored or not, the whole of the ball has to cross the line, not just the where the bottom of the ball touches the playing surface, because we have all seen the ball go over the line on the bottom, but it does not count if the bit that sticks out is not over the line. Why does that not also apply to corner kicks?

There are a great many sports that now rely on technology to assist in getting the right decisions made. Do you think technology be introduced into football for the same purpose, and if so for what purpose?

It always amazes me when player running into the box fall down so easily, but when they score a goal, they run around like maniacs and no matter how much the other players jump and tug at their shirts they still keep running and hardly ever seem to go down under the challenges of their colleagues.

Is there some of the rules that you would change?

Here are few members comments...

mcfcthriller - I've always said to my father at the games - I think there should be a rule that stops time wasting especially around corner flag!!!

Yellow cards or the wasted time added on. I don`t care if it's to hang on, you just have to keep attacking if you need to secure a win - we pay to see our team play and win but we also want to see entertainment, enjoying the games. Win the right way!

If you can't win the right way that means you need to improve your game or means simply you`re not good enough!

BlueWolfie - Injury/added time - that is what has always bothered me.

End of the first half, you probably don't see more than a minute or two, but at the end of the second, it can be anything from 1 to 6 minutes.

Be consistent, if a player is injured (whether real or not), or the ref has to sort out a dispute, then add the full length of it, regardless of which half it happened in.

SIR TROYSTER - I think goal line technology is a must, like in tennis with the hawk eye. I mean people say it will add on to much time on a game, well then how come it's shown within seconds on the telly and there`s no disputing the result and it doesn`t put that much added time on at all, with all the tech that they have now such as ear and mic's pieces and pitch side monitors there should be no excuse. At the end of the day a goal that's given that wasn't over the line could if it's not already happened send some one down resulting in major loss of revenue

Sindbad - I really like the 'sin-bin' idea -- but the problem is that we would have to trust the referees to get it right. A 'sin-bin' could increase the number of decisions which the ref makes during a game. If it's a poor ref then it empowers him to make more of a hash of it. But if the 'sin-bin' offences were very clearly defined then it could work.

Over-celebration would be a case in point. A booking for that is ridiculous.

The above is just a snippet of what fans have been saying. To view the whole thread, click here.





For the very latest Premier League odds

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Writer:Tudor
Date:Tuesday July 7 2009
Time: 10:36PM

Comments

0
Time keeping - have an independent time keeper removing the responsibilty from the ref. Arguments over added time would then disappear. It works in Rugby, Ice Hockey basketball etc.
tdfkap
07/07/2009 23:32:00
0
why dont goalkeepers who pretent to be injured have to go off like any other player ??
Mike Hunt
08/07/2009
0
I'd like to see the introduction of a sniper in the stands, two fouls and you're gone, bullet to the head. I've heard it's been trialed in the Kabul National Stadium to great effect. No doubt killjoy, wire haired, nonchalontly shrugging, poison midget, Real Madrid loving UEFA president Platini will find something to moan about though, he usually does! Bah!
RobsonGreensleeves
08/07/2009 00:48:00
0
Work out how a "sin-bin" for minor infractions could be brought in by a fourth official. Take away the ability of referees to book players for taking shirts off, over-celebrating and so on. Make them a responsibility of a fourth official to allocate a number of minutes off the field.
Sindbad
08/07/2009 01:50:00
0
Something they do in Basket ball 5 fouls and you're off, into the sin bin for 10 minutes.
Buzz Lightyear
08/07/2009 04:29:00
Page 1/1
  1. 1

Login to post a comment

Recent Manchester City Articles

Premier League Team Of The Season So Far (25/3/17)

The Team of the Season so far based on statistical scoring points has now been released.

A Premier League Brexit Breakdown

The numbers have been crunched from the Brexit vote and details have now been given for each local authority to provide an 'idea' of how fans of each Premier...

Premier League's Last 20 Goal A Season Scorers

Every club in the Premier League aspires to unearth, develop or sign a guaranteed 20 goals a season kind of striker but they are always in short supply.

Whose Your Clubs' Lucky Scoring Omen?

Some clubs in the Premier League just seem to have a player with lady luck on their side and when they score in a game, that match always returns at least a point.

Archived VMC Articles

VMC articles from

Site Journalists

Tudor (VMC Editor)
Editor email
Profile
Johnny Baguette
no email
Profile
Pedmachine
no email
Profile
Skoorb
no email
Profile

Current Poll (see more polls)

I am viewing VMC from...?
Suggested By: Tudor
United Kingdom38%
Republic of Ireland0%
North America0%
South America0%
Asia0%
Africa12%
Europe25%
Australia / New Zealand 25%
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites

League Table

# Team P W D L Pts. GD
1 Chelsea 28 22 3 3 69 38
2 Spurs 28 17 8 3 59 34
3 Man City 28 17 6 5 57 24
4 Liverpool 29 16 8 5 56 25
5 Man Utd 27 14 10 3 52 19
6 Arsenal 27 15 5 7 50 22
7 Everton 29 14 8 7 50 21
8 WBA 29 12 7 10 43 1
9 Stoke 29 9 9 11 36 -9
10 Southampton 27 9 6 12 33 -3
11 AFC Bournemouth 29 9 6 14 33 -12
12 West Ham 29 9 6 14 33 -12
13 Burnley 29 9 5 15 32 -11
14 Watford 28 8 7 13 31 -15
15 Leicester City 28 8 6 14 30 -14
16 Crystal Palace 28 8 4 16 28 -10
17 Swansea 29 8 3 18 27 -27
18 Hull City 29 6 6 17 24 -32
19 Middlesbrough 28 4 10 14 22 -13
20 Sunderland 28 5 5 18 20 -26
Write for Vital Football
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
The Vital Football Members League

Recent Manchester City Results (view all)

Manchester City Fixtures (view all)

Apr 2 2017 4:00PM : Arsenal (a)
Barclays Premier League
Apr 5 2017 8:00PM : Chelsea (a)
Barclays Premier League
Apr 8 2017 3:00PM : Hull City (H)
Barclays Premier League
Apr 15 2017 5:30PM : Southampton (a)
Barclays Premier League
Apr 22 2017 12:30PM : West Bromwich Albion (H)
Barclays Premier League
Apr 23 2017 3:00PM : Arsenal (a)
FA Cup

Vital Members League Table

RankNamePoints
1.Buzz Lightyear706
2.Johnny Baguette610
3.Skoorb349
4.Rising146
5.kennyclementstache130
6.johnkelv124
7.Tudor121
8.Colin Is The King102
9.citizhun78
10.Bluedub72
Vital Football Comment