Vital Football

Latest Manchester City News

Emmanuel Adebayor Affair: Justice, What Justice

Emmanuel Adebayor Affair: Justice, What Justice

Avid Manchester City fan, Stephen Williams sent us the following:

It used to be a proud boast of English justice that one was innocent until proven guilty. Another principle was the judicial decision makers were not influenced by outside comment especially from those in High Office before or during the judiciary process. Obviously the English football disciplinary processes and the people who run our game or are involved in it have never heard of such principles.

Let us look at the way Emmanuel Adebayor has been treated in this respect by the FA, the Premier League, Arsenal Football Club, the Police and the vast majority of tawdry hacks that have put pen to paper in at attempt to produce the most sensational headlines they could manage

Firstly, Mr Ian Watmore FA Chief Executive (and reportedly a big Arsenal fan) comments that the disciplinary commission will be having a good look at both incidents. Which is fine given his role but then he has to add 'I was pretty unimpressed'. Very reassuring for all those that want an unbiased approach by out footballing judicial masters and rather like the Chief Justice saying the 'accused will get a fair trial even though he's plainly guilty of the most horrendous of crimes'

Secondly, we have Richard Scudamore of the Premier League who proved himself totally incapable of maintaining a neutral position before the judicial process was complete by saying that Adebayor has 'hurt our image and brought shame on the game'. That was obviously intended to put more pressure on the disciplinary commission and perhaps a lynching might be more to Mr Scudamore's taste. Let's just hope his sense of justice is never questioned as it would be found sadly wanting.

Thirdly, we have Arsenal Football Club for it was they would sanctioned the usage of their official website for the attack on his fellow professional by Van Persie. Now this is a very sinister development in inter club relationships and is even worse than a player trying to get another one booked by waving an imaginary card in front of the referee.

Now we have a mechanism by which one club is trying to get the players from another banned from games. Perhaps next Arsenal might take a full page advert in the Times or a TV commercial to make their pleas and just think Arsenal FC were once regarded as the bastion of respectability. Sorry Arsenal FC you have been shown as sneaky and stab in the back merchants, particularly as your fans were hardly innocent of using vile and racist chants or of throwing missiles on the pitch and Mr Van Persie's tackle hardly came from the fair play manual.

Then we have some fellow that was an ex-Metropolitan Police Commander (and probably a rabid Arsenal fan) called John O'Connor, that some hack has no doubt found in a North London watering hole drowning his sorrows. He was quoted as saying 'I'm sure the police will want Adebayor to be made an example of...hic...'

Thank goodness the current Commissioner of the Met Police is a Tottenham fan or no doubt he would have called it a riot and the boys in blue would have been racing up to Manchester in their vans with batons at the ready and a warrant for Adebayor's arrest.

We then have Manchester United football club and that bastion of good taste and fair play Piers Morgan throwing in their two penny worth and finally a galaxy of hacks with their sensational copy. If you read them at face value you would think that Mr Adebayor had raped, pillaged and committed treason before blowing up FA headquarters with a nuclear warhead.

What did he actually do...erm celebrate a goal he had scored in front of a crowd of people who had abused him for 70 odd minutes and then allegedly stamp on a player that had tacked him studs up and if he had made contact could have ended his season if not his career.

Please also note that I did say 'allegedly' because I defy anyone watching the 'incident' at normal speed to say it was a stamp. No commentator did, the referee didn't and none of the crowd did. It was only when the slow mo was shown that the lynch mob took shape.

From my point of view when you are unbalanced by a studs up tackle, it is hard to keep your total balance and your feet can go anywhere. Yes they can go into a stamp or they can try and avoid your opponents hand or they can accidentally make contact.

The process of justice will decide this but how can it, when the head of the FA, the head of the Premier League, Arsenal FC and our tawdry Fifth Estate have already decided the outcome? Shame on the lot of them and particularly messrs Scudamore and Watmore as they are clearly not fit for their positions and are merely puppets mouthing what the faceless power merchants behind them require.

The most important thing for Manchester City FC is to recognise what your are up against in terms of the footballing establishment and to stick together and to have a siege mentality as you will need it in the months ahead. Chelsea were similarly treated and this proved to be an effective response. I just hope those that run MCFC do not suck up to these people and just accept the over the top punishment that will be meted out and then carry on regardless.

Our time will come and then these people will suddenly become all positive - hideous but true I am afraid.

Bookmark and Share

*Try Vital Mobile FOR FREE for the latest news, scores, fixtures and so much more*

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Writer:Stephen Williams
Date:Tuesday September 15 2009
Time: 1:30PM


ssn saying fa charge ade with violent conduct and improper conduct 2 charges
15/09/2009 13:36:00
although quite how he can be done for improper conduct i will never know didnt he already get done for that with a yellow card?
15/09/2009 13:37:00
S'funny - I just sent a somewhat similar article in, concerning the media and City in general. But you are right of course, it does seem (even if not true) that the FA are being pushed into only one direction, by the countless voices.
15/09/2009 13:38:00
addey always celebrates by sliding at away fans,he did it at blackburn.he did it against us at the emirates last year.
15/09/2009 13:39:00
He's a disgrace and should have a ten match ban at least. What he did was totally unacceptable. Van Persie will be scarred and provoking the fans like that evidently identified massive insecurities about his Arsenal years. the blokes a doughnut and has made himself and his club look like clowns.
15/09/2009 13:46:00
I think that is the most truthful and appropriate article I have seen on this issue anywhere. I applaud your every word Steve. Well said.
15/09/2009 13:49:00
leelindsay isnt that a girls name?, arsenal are a disgrace the press incited all the trouble that the arsenal fans caused they acted like animals just because someone scores against them, ask your board to spend some of the 100s of millions they have earned from the sale of players and then maybe you might not be so bitter when players leave your trampy club who refuse to pay above 1990s wages you are the most bitter and twisted fans ive ever met and your bitter at your board but take it out on outgoing players because there an easy target TELL YOUR BOARD TO SPEND SOME CASH THEN THE ARSENAL FANS MIGHT BE ABIT HAPPIER AND MIGHT NOT BE SO BITTER TOWARDS EX PLAYERS
15/09/2009 13:56:00
***** you... he’s not a disgrace Arsenal fans are the disgrace and RVP the girly man! FA can kiss my ass... idiots in suits who think they are intelligent but are uneducated in the real world
15/09/2009 13:58:00
He should get banned for the stamp on RVP. I hate Arsenal with a passion, but they have every reason to be angered by his assault. Anyone (and it does seem like alot of you) who thinks otherwise really needs to take off their light blue tinted specs!
15/09/2009 14:04:00
huddyiddo we all agree he should get banned but what we dont agree on is the time honoured kickin the press keep giving us constant anti city dribble being wrote, the press get the arsenal fans worked up into a frenzy and so the press should take some of the blame
15/09/2009 14:13:00
Page 1/2
  1. 1
  2. 2

Login to post a comment

Recent Manchester City Articles

Man City v QPR: Purest Sound Ever Made In Human History

The goal sound to end all goal sounds. The Premier League's greatest moment. It won't get any better than this, and here's the greatest video of it.

Exclusive: Unseen Footage Of Jose's 12 Minute Rant

With just over two weeks to go unto Jose (Maureen) Mourinho brings his Manchester United side to the Etihad we at VMC thought we'd take a brief look at our opponents.

British Clubs Who Appeared In Major European Finals

COFFEE BREAK QUIZ: Can you name all 19 British clubs to appear in a major European final?

City Already Confident For Liverpool

I'm sure a fair few of us took in highlights of Liverpool's win at the weekend and the amount of attacking praise that they got on shows like Match of the Day.

Manchester City Archived Articles

VMC articles from

Site Journalists

Editor email
Johnny Baguette
no email
no email
no email

Current Poll (see more polls)

When Joe Hart leaves City, for good in the summer where will he go?
Suggested By: Tudor
Another Premier League team58%
Lower league English side3%
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites
Vital Football Comment
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
Write for Vital Football

Recent Manchester City Results (view all)

Manchester City Fixtures

Vital Members League Table

1.Johnny Baguette363
3.Buzz Lightyear186
5.Colin Is The King163
The Vital Football Members League