Vital Football

Latest Manchester City News

Same Old City

Same Old City

Vital Manchester City member, discopants28 vents his spleen over the latest Eastlands debacle.

Us City fans are more than accustomed to stupid decisions based on knee-jerk reactions and ill-founded opinion. But December's embarrassing removal of Mark Hughes tops the lot. Over the decades we've felt many negative emotions as fans of this once great club - humiliation, despair, desperation, but never shame. Shame shame shame. We're in dangerous new territory.

The new regime presiding over Manchester City hardly resembles a group of businessmen representing fans' hopes and dreams. Instead it's easier to liken them to The Dark Side (Lucasfilm copyright pending) as Darth Khaldoon Vader carries out his work for the dark Lord Mansour - by employing henchmen Cook and Marwood to fulfill their dark plotting - ably assisted by a blue clone army of emotionless mercenary footballers. Is this what we have been dreaming for all our live long football lives? Is this what Young, Tueart and Dickov fought for on the fields of Wembley? Is this what I queued 8 hours at Maine Road for in 1999? Is this the reason I actually paid real money to watch Lee Bradbury kick air? Is it? Huh? I suppose I should be grateful for what City has become. Well you know what Gary Cook - I'd rather watch Jamie Pollock score a comical, 3rd division propelling own goal than have to bear you managing the day to day affairs of my club.

But I'm getting ahead of myself, although I must admit I feel better already. And relax. And breathe.

The one glaringly obvious problem on the field this season is the defence. We conceded several poor goals; often from winning positions and have made life difficult for ourselves - which was all highlighted in the 4-3 victory (Yes - victory!) against Sunderland. City fans everywhere, on websites and radio shows cited Hughes as responsible for not signing an experienced and reliable centre half. You know who you are. And if you do know who you are, I hope you won't mind me saying that you're wrong.

Can anyone guess who was actually responsible for this? Yes, you at the back with bitter blue tears running down your face; correct, it's Gary Cook! My mate Gary thought it made more business and football sense to try and nab John Terry from Chelsea, while also forcing Richard Dunne by gunpoint on a mega bus to Birmingham. Terry was never going to leave Chelsea - an utterly fruitless task. And Dunne had been the heartbeat of the defence - own goals aside - for years. Sparky`s plan for the season was to make our longest serving player Captain - and build the defence around him. Should Lescott or Toure have ousted him - Dunney would have been more than happy to fight for his place. Instead Cook sells Dunne to the Villa against the manager's and player's wishes. There was little outcry from the fans - instead sentiments like 'thanks Dunney - but you`re not good enough to take us forward', were echoed by the populous. It seems we were guilty of believing our own hype. The same kinds of comments have last week been made about Hughes. How wrong everybody has been. Dunne is proving Villa's saviour as they look most likely to take 4th spot from Liverpool this season.

This makes Hughes' sacking even harder to accept - had Cook not interfered and shipped Dunne out 'because we needed the money', (cough cough) our defence would have been stronger and more familiar. Instead Sparky gets the public hanging which Cook deserves. Let's not feel too sorry for MH - but this decision is undeniably the wrong decision to take at this point in the season. Which leads me on to his successor?

Just who the hell is Roberto Mancini? The guy can't even speak English! Yes I know all about Mancini the player - he's a legend. But so is Gazza. At least Brian Horton had managed in English football - Roberto who? Mamma mia!

This whole shambolic series of events begs the question - who is Man City? Who are we supporting? Does it even matter anymore?

I'm based in London nowadays and have spent much of my time wishing I could see City more often. But now I don't recognise anything except the colour of the shirt. I might as well start supporting Wingate & Finchley in the Ryman League. At least then I might get a discount on paper clips for my work. Had United or Chelsea behaved in this manner we'd be chastising them.

In the seventies, Peter Swales made the regular mistake of acting irrationally, without thought of consequence. In 2010 football may be very different. But it's same old City.

Bookmark and Share

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Date:Wednesday December 30 2009
Time: 12:27AM


This must be a wind up or it is from the most irrational Man City fan I can imagaine. Fair do's every one is entitled to an opinion but this is so off the wall it could almost be written by Sir Alex Ferguson.
30/12/2009 00:52:00
This drivel by Discopants does not belong on the front page of Vital Manchester City. I'm sure Wingate and Finchley eagerly await your support.
30/12/2009 01:11:00
jesus man........ENJOY IT!!!!!! ctid
30/12/2009 01:18:00
thats meant for discopants by the way,wasnt having a go at you dakeb :)
30/12/2009 01:19:00
Stay in London then, you sound like a right t.w.a.t. I ****ing hate people like you. [Edited by tudor]
30/12/2009 02:37:00
Thats called self control....believe me!
30/12/2009 02:37:00
I think you will find that the majority of City fans, were not best pleased at the way the City management dealt with Mr Hughes termination at City and we quite rightly pointed the finger once again for making City look foolish, but also that same majority of fans who pay good money to watch City and buy the goods on offer at the shop recognised that the defence was not doing their job. Mr Mancini arrives, he immediately sees the problem and tries to do something about it, without buying anyone else. He changes tactics mid game because he sees something not right, he sees the balance not right, mid game he changes that. We have not had a manager brave enough to do that for many years. I don't think Mr Hughes was going to change his style of defence, I know you will say it was only Stoke and Wolves, but have a look at our clean sheets since his arrival result we win matches. We used to dream some season how we were going to get to that magic 40 point mark. Halfway through the season just 5 points short. We have progressed, Thanks to the Sheikh, thanks to Mark Hughes for his judgement in the players he bought. I just hope that they don't shaft Mancini the way they did Hughes, but I wouldn't complain to a public dismissal of Cook and Marwood, just so they know how Hughesy felt.
Buzz Lightyear
30/12/2009 04:38:00
I have read some ***** on Vital over the years but this tops it.
30/12/2009 05:51:00
I'm sure admin sometimes put these front page articles up just for a wind up - a well written article but the only thing i can side with is on Mr.Cook, who i think is an out and out w***er. As for Mancini, only time will tell, but his tactical changes in the last two games gives me hope for the immediate future. Move on mate, like Buzz i don't want to go back to the times when i was relieved at making the magical 40pts mark.
30/12/2009 07:54:00
Rag WUM.
30/12/2009 09:29:00
Page 1/3
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3

Login to post a comment

Recent Manchester City Articles

Plane Hopping

Today's eight hour flight from Abu Dhabi to Manchester will see 14 senior City players find themselves hopping from one aircraft to another as they prepare..

The Ped UCL Draw Report

Hotballers Get Their Precise Wish...I Wonder Why?

Best Of Blue Moon Rising TV & What The Boys Do Now

Paul Walsh, Steven Mcinerney and Alex Hylton were the backbone of the now defunct Manchester City fans YouTube channel, Blue Moon Rising TV.

Concept City Kit Causes A Stir

This part of the season always has plenty of exciting things going on and one of those facets, that I always enjoy, is the amount of kit concepts we see coming out.

Manchester City Archived Articles

VMC articles from

Site Journalists

Editor email
Johnny Baguette
no email
no email
no email

Current Poll (see more polls)

UCL quarter-finals: City face Liverpool
Suggested By: Tudor
As a Blue I'm delighted6%
Would have preferred another team45%
Not bothered either way49%
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites
The Vital Football Members League
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
Vital Football Comment

Recent Manchester City Results (view all)

Manchester City Fixtures

Vital Members League Table

1.Johnny Baguette363
3.Buzz Lightyear180
4.Colin Is The King162
Write for Vital Football