Vital Football

Latest Manchester City News

Negative Italian Tactics Not To Blame

Negative Italian Tactics Not To Blame

Clarkey311 sent us the following.

Since the initial success of Mancini's fledgling spell as manager has somewhat dried up, all I have read on message boards and in the media alike are that Mancini plays too much of a defensive system and isn't willing to gamble for the win.

After the recent stalemate against Liverpool however, there is a very good argument that these negative tactics are forced by the squad lacking personal within some key areas.

The common misconception amongst fans of our beloved club is that because Mancini is from an Italian background, he must therefore be renowned for his 'negative Italian tactics', far from it in fact.

At Inter he played some of the most adventurous football in the league and I would point you towards the title he won with a magnificent ninety-seven points scoring eighty goals whilst playing his favoured two holding midfielders in the centre which we have become accustom to.

The problems currently facing Mancini's system is the lack real flair and leadership within the midfield. At Inter he had a mixture Zanetti, Cambiasso and Vieira at his disposal in the centre of midfield, providing both a solid defensive platform and commanding leadership. Ahead of the before mentioned players, Mancini's sides included Stankovic, Figo, Ibrahimovic and Suazo all creative flair players capable of producing pieces of individuals brilliance at any given time as well as combining with each other.

Within our current squad there are isn't a player that could even come close to matching any of the flair players mentioned, bar Robinho who as we have all witnessed isn`t a team player. 'One day I would like to be the number one as well, the best player in the world. That is my aim while I am at Manchester City' - Robinho shortly after signing.

Some would argue that Bellamy could be thrown into the flair bracket, but he really lacks the trickery and vision required, despite the work rate and pace. Given last year's performances, Ireland was looking to have more than enough of the creative traits required for Hughes to comfortably allow Elano to leave, yet hasn't really played anywhere near the level we know he can . Meanwhile Elano being an international starter for Brazil with bags of vision and flair, yet dogged by patchy form, a player whom I believe would have only flourished under Mancini's guidance, much like he did under Sven initially, was allowed to leave cheaply.

Having been appointed so near the start of the transfer window, Mancini didn't have very long to work out what each member within the squad could bring to the team, not to mention a rather large cup tie taking up most of his attention. He did clearly attempt to rectify the two problems with the signing of Vieira (leadership) and Johnson (flair) but this still isn't his squad, I'm sure given the money available in the summer he would of bought very few of the player Hughes did. I'm also under the impression that the owners don't want to throw money at another manager's mercy without them proving they deserve the opportunity.

Currently we are really missing a link between the forwards and the midfield whilst playing Barry and de Jong in the centre, there is a real lack of forward drive. Both are very neat and tidy players and solid enough when it comes to protecting the defence but there is no forward momentum on display, so this falls heavily on the wingers.

Johnson has fulfilled this in every game he has featured in so far with his jinking runs and no fear attitude, however finding someone of equal effectiveness on the other flank has proven to be an upward battle for Mancini. Both Petrov and Wright-Phillips go missing in games far too often, especially against the more competitive teams and Bellamy has had trouble adapting to Mancini's training methods, or more to the point his knee has, despite what the media would like you to believe.

A short term fix which Mancini has used frequently thus far is to play a player behind the striker, however once again the squad is very short in personal able to play this role to a high enough standard. Tevez has been the preferred player so far and has been clearly missed over the last couple fixtures. Ireland took over this role against Liverpool and was completely missing in action; worst of all was the incredible work rate commonly associated with the Irishman had also disappeared much like his confidence.

Another common suggestion amongst fans is to player 4-4-2 with Santa Cruz and Adebayor up top, but once again the link is missing for the most part. Adebayor started his City career with a goal which he instigated by coming deep to get the ball and playing Wright-Phillips into space, since then this aspect of his game seems to have vanished or be in vain as he is often the target man and has no one ahead to link up with. With a fellow target man in Santa Cruz up front, Adebayor should be encouraged to drop deep once again in an attempt to link up play giving us another option rather than an aimless punt up field in his general direction.

Mancini's tactics shouldn't be criticised to the extent they are, they are proven to win things in a league often referred to as most tactical in Europe. Given time and resources Mancini will turn us into a force, remember before Mancini's arrival at Inter they had gone seven years without a trophy and a further sixteen without a league title. Some discredit his achievements at Inter because he had the strongest squad after the Calciopoli scandal, yet if the players aren't managed correctly then ultimately you won't succeed in winning anything, the Real Madrid Galáctico's are the perfect example of this.

Bookmark and Share

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Date:Monday February 22 2010
Time: 9:01PM


It was worth the wait for your entrance Clarkey - brilliant stuff.
22/02/2010 21:37:00
Food for thought. Everyone likes a good witch hunt, and a scapegoat though, don't they?
It's Grim Oop North
22/02/2010 22:14:00
Top stuff clarkey, we have been lacking that M Johnson esque, box to box midfielder for ages now. And you're spot about the squad. It is still hughes's team and mancini offer to have the chance to put his stamp on it and bring in some top quality players
22/02/2010 22:58:00
Clarkey i take my hat off too you, and that should be posted over to Sheikh Mansour so he keep Roberto and let him build his own team.
22/02/2010 22:59:00
Yes he is to blame... this is the worst football I've seen us play in years. You can say he's shoring up the leaky defense but that's rubbish... set pieces was our major problem and he's gone zonal which has seemed to help. Playing football at 1mph with 10 men back is boring and dire to watch. Seeing as this is all due to a lack of personnel though it's not his fault... but wait.... even Hughes had us playing good football... and scoring goals. In fact we've scored more in the league than everyone outside the top 4. Not bad for a squad lacking. It's funny how when defending a manager people can say not got the attacking players and yet most professionals would say we've got some of the best attacking players in the league.
23/02/2010 09:31:00
I've just watched Mancini's press conference regarding Tevez and the Stoke game and the so called players revolt, and i personally think it's just a question of this squad of players adapting 100% to his tactics his training methods and the overall way he wants the team too perform depending on who the opposition are. Yes I'm sure it's a culture shock to one or two of the players and the fact it's not his squad of players that he signed, In my opinion all these factors are obviously having an effect because we've only won two out of the last seven games. But I maintain that he will get this right in the end, I think it's going to be very frustrating for us supporters at this stage of the season because we want to see free flowing football, But it's a results game, and speaking for myself if we continue playing dour football that results in us finishing fourth, I'll take it now thank you very much. After all thats all that matters isn't it. Finally he confirmed tevez is back on friday, that will do for me.
23/02/2010 18:48:00
'After all thats all that matters isn't it.' ........ personally I watch football for the entertainment 1st... success would be fantastic but unlike most I'm happy just to see good entertaining football.
23/02/2010 22:52:00
Page 1/1
  1. 1

Login to post a comment

Recent Manchester City Articles

The Ped Cup Report Wigan Athletic 1-0 City

Conclusion: Gonefour

The FA Cup Fifth Round Aftermath: Wigan 1-0 Man City

It seems as though Manchester City FC are either incapable, or simply inept when it comes to beating Wigan Athletic in the FA Cup.

Player Ratings (Honest Opinion) Vs Wigan

Twelve hours after Wigan's fat lady cleared her throat and sung her lungs out, my intention is not to moan over my morning bowl of cornflakes but instead, give my honest City player opinion ratings.<

Stats: Wigan Athletic v Manchester City

All the stats from Wigan Athletic (1) vs (0) Manchester City, DW Stadium, 19/2/18 19h55 GMT Att: 19, 242

Manchester City Archived Articles

VMC articles from

Site Journalists

Editor email
Johnny Baguette
no email
no email
no email

Current Poll (see more polls)

Rate City's overall performance, out of five against Wigan?
Suggested By: Tudor
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites
The Vital Football Members League
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
Vital Football Comment

Recent Manchester City Results (view all)

Manchester City Fixtures

Vital Members League Table

1.Johnny Baguette317
2.Buzz Lightyear272
4.Colin Is The King191
Write for Vital Football