Manchester City - The Buck Stops With Under Performing Players
UK time is: 15:27:45
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

The Buck Stops With Under Performing Players

Vital Manchester City stalwart, Kevinho sent us the following.

I no doubt spent Wednesday night as frustrated as any other City fan as I watched on resigned to the fact that we will be going another season without a trophy. We have been having our best season in years as we reached a Carling Cup semi-final and are currently lying fifth in the Premier League with a game in hand and only goal difference separating us from that all important fourth Champions League place.

Lack of creativity

At the same time I find myself distinctly under-whelmed by some of our performances of late as we have lacked creativity and cutting edge in front of goal and in some ways like any other season I can't wait for this season to end so that we can start again and rebuild for our assault next season as I really can't see us making the top 4 on current form with the way that we are playing.

A lot of people were quick to jump on the back of Roberto Mancini following the FA Cup defeat - being bullied by Stoke some might say and whilst I respect their opinions I don't necessarily agree with them. However the jury is still out for Mancini in my opinion despite him being 1 of about 4 managers who were on my own personal shortlist after we sacked Mark Hughes.

Track record

The Italian has a proven track record in Serie A but he now seems to be finding the Premier League a whole different ball game. I like Mancini as a person and really hope that he is the manager to turn City into a major English and European force but I have always harboured doubts about his long term future following the '6 months and then 3 years' comment at his press conference unveiling and the fact that he wasn't really backed during the January transfer window, although this admittedly isn't the best time to do business with plenty of overpriced panic buys usually being the norm.

He may have been the owner's choice as manager but I feel that he got the job because he was available during December unlike other possible leading contenders. I still however live in hope that he can get things back on track in the closing months of the season with excellent displays of attacking football and is still here to bring in his own players in the summer so that we can launch a more solid challenge next season and then he can be more harshly judged but I can't help but think that the owners will dispense with his services too during the summer.

What really grinds my gears?

The people that really irritate me most in all of this other than the British press with their 'build them up, knock them down' mentality and our own official club website which in all honesty tries to make us look like the biggest club in the world before we are even in the top 4 in England with all of their propaganda, are some of the players themselves. It is as if some of them don't give a toss at the end of the day as if a manager is deemed to have failed he will eventually come under scrutiny and will then get the sack but the players still get paid their £80k to £150k a week regardless of what they do on a Saturday or Sunday afternoon or midweek evening.

Money, money, money

Some of them of late seem more interested in inviting The Sun into their homes to brag about how they've spent around £100k on their aquarium and show off their vast collection of cars or to talk about how hard done by that they are as they are only earning in the bracket of £60k to £80k a week and want even more when they have become a peripheral figure of late - Some of these players should spare a thought for the millions of unemployed in the UK who get paid a damned sight less a week for doing about as much as some of these jokers who are multi-millionaires.

If these newspaper stories and contract talks are really that necessary then they surely can wait until the summer so that players can fully focus on football as after all it's what they get paid to do and us as fans, critics and customers can get back to enjoying quality football which is important to each of us. Players really must earn the right through their performances on the pitch before they go knocking on the Chairman`s door doing their Oliver Twist impression by asking for more.

Carlos Tevez

For me the only player this season who probably deserves a pay rise is Carlos Tevez and he is probably one of our highest earners anyway. His goals and never say die attitude from the first whistle to the final whistle are the main reason for our league position in my opinion and we usually look like a one man team when he isn't around, none more so than at the moment.

A major failing for me this season has been the inefficiency of our midfield - It has plenty of bite but very little creative spark. Despite him not being a very hard worker and an alleged bad influence I really feel that we would have benefited from having Elano in our current central midfield set-up alongside so many defensive midfielders as he could often pick out the crucial defence splitting passes.


Steven Ireland is the only player currently in this mould at the club but he has been poor and largely ineffective this season going by the standards that he set for himself last season when he deservedly won the supporters player of the year award. People may point to him not being in the team week in, week out, a bit like SWP too but there has been a very good reason for this, they haven't performed as we all know they can.

The other major failing in the team for me is a lack of leadership in the team. Mark Hughes appointed Kolo Toure as our captain during the summer and I thought that this was a bad move as it guaranteed his place in the team week in, week out; when in my opinion he simply isn't good enough and was a total waste of £16 million. Shay Given and Gareth Barry aren't the answer either as goalkeepers very rarely make good captains and Givens form has dipped a bit in the last 6 weeks or so and Barry has been a big disappointment in my opinion and is lucky to be such a permanent fixture in our first 11 and I dread to think what the added burden of captaincy would do to him.

Captain Kompany?

The ever impressive Vincent Kompany should be captain for me, from the centre of our defence as we could really benefit from a settled back 5 of Given in goal, Kompany and Lescott at centre half, Bridge at left back and Richards at right back - This would hopefully give us the ideal base to build from and push on.

I really hope that we can have a decent end to the season and win plenty of matches as after all our fate is currently in our own hands as we have most of the clubs around us still to play, many of which are at home but one thing is for sure, the players will really need to stand up and be counted from now on, starting at Stamford Bridge on Saturday lunchtime.

Bookmark and Share

Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

The journalist

Writer: Kevinho  Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Friday February 26 2010

Time: 1:22AM

Your Comments (oldest first)

Change to most recent first
Great article Kev - you echo mine, and i think most fans, feelings about the team and certain individuals. A well written article mate.
Report Abuse
26/02/2010 03:11:00

For your firs, you certainly did a bang-up job. (insert clappy smiley here)
Report Abuse
26/02/2010 07:03:00

Excellent job Kev. You have pretty much hit the nail on the head with your points. I share your optimism for the rest of the season and I think there is plenty of room for improvement between now and then.
Report Abuse
26/02/2010 09:34:00

Morning Kev, Firstly wonderfully written thread and well worth the wait and i think you've more or less covered all your bases with every concern regarding the the club, the first team and the whole infrastructure of the club.
Report Abuse
26/02/2010 10:11:00

couldnt agree with you more but i think mancini only a stop gap,,,,,,,,,,,,mourinho in next for me sort team owt bigsyle..........chassone
Report Abuse
26/02/2010 13:52:00

10 out of 10 article. I agree with everything, especially with players under performing.
Super City Slicker
Report Abuse
26/02/2010 14:06:00

Great shout about elano. He made the attacking edge to citys midfield. Just look at the dismal performances of robinho, ireland and swp this season.
Super City Slicker
Report Abuse
26/02/2010 14:08:00

Spot. On. Kev.
Report Abuse
26/02/2010 14:22:00


Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Manchester City Articles

Toure Out, Pogba & Sterling In? (Wednesday May 20 2015)

Villa Confirm Sinclair Transfer (Wednesday May 20 2015)

One Last Milner Offer? (Tuesday May 19 2015)

Toure Hails Joe Hart (Monday May 18 2015)

Jake's Swansea Report (Sunday May 17 2015)

Audio - Pellegrini Talks Toure (Sunday May 17 2015)

Archived Manchester City Articles

List All VMC Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites

Vital Members League (view all)

1. Johnny Baguette 337
2. Bluedub 209
3. Buzz Lightyear 123
4. Skoorb 122
5. Colin Is The King 118
6. citizhun 111
7. OziMan 94
8. CITYBOY1000 87
9. kennyclementstache 81
10. johnkelv 69

League Results (view all)

Latest Results
Swansea 2 - 4 Man City
Man City 6 - 0 Q.P.R.
Spurs 0 - 1 Man City
Man City 3 - 2 Aston Villa
Man City 2 - 0 West Ham
Man Utd 4 - 2 Man City

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
1. Chelsea 37 25 9 3 +39 84
2. Man City 37 23 7 7 +43 76
3. Arsenal 37 21 9 7 +32 72
4. Man Utd 37 20 9 8 +25 69
5. Liverpool 37 18 8 11 +9 62
6. Spurs 37 18 7 12 +4 61
7. Southampton 37 18 6 13 +23 60

Breaking League News

Something For The Weekend (494)
» Aston Villa : 22/05/2015 15:24:00
Liverpool: The Weekly LFC News Update
» Liverpool : 22/05/2015 14:40:01
Jose Holds Court - Sunderland (h)
» Chelsea : 22/05/2015 13:46:01
Wenger - Gunners Looking To Sign Off In Style
» Arsenal : 22/05/2015 13:15:01
Wenger Confident Arsenal Will Return To Scoring Wa
» Arsenal : 22/05/2015 12:56:01

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Your Favourite Goal In The Slaying Of Swansea?
Suggested By:  Shaun Gloater
Touré 21′ 20%
Touré 74′ 13%
Milner 36′ 45%
Bony 90′ 22%