Manchester City - Maybe Messi Is Right?
UK time is: 19:18:22
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

Maybe Messi Is Right?

Is Lionel Messi correct in his assessment that City are 2 world class defenders away from seriously challenging for major honours?

Last night's workout in the inaugural Ferrosataal Cup challenge appeared to add some weight to what Messi is telling us.

A strong looking City side went behind early on when a needless foul by Barry gave Dortmund and easy penalty. A Premier League referee might even have seen Barry heading for the sanctity of the changing rooms. Barrios stuttering run-up perhaps fooled Hart more than the shot, but despite Joe diving the right way, the ball squeezed inside the post.

City came back quickly and strongly. Toure Yaya played the kind of pass out of defence that was missing all last season - a straight ball picking out Adebayor, who quickly sent Wright-Phillips off down the right wing. An early pass which for once reached the far post and a miskick by Jo went in off the goalkeeper to make it 1-1.

The game ebbed and flowed with new-signing Kolarov looking particularly good, not only in open play but also from free kick situations.

However on the stroke of half time the ref presented Dortmund with another chance from the spot when he penalised Kolarov somewhat harshly for a push and once again it was Barrios v Hart.

Barrios stop/start run-up left him short of space to get any real pace on the ball, Joe guessed right again and made and excellent save to his right.

The second half saw a number of changes and Shay Given , now in for Hart was busy quickly and defensive frailty gave Kasawa the opportunity to restore Dortmund's lead.

Kolarov tried his best with a couple of free kicks and from one delivered the kind of cross that centre forwards love, except this time it fell to the rather wooden Santa Cruz, who didn't get there and neither did Lescott running in behind.

Then with a few minutes left we saw the kind of calamitous defending that we were hoping we'd left behind but that was highlighted by Messi in his comments yesterday.

Kolo Toure found himself drawn to the ball on Lescott's side of the field, his attempted clearance bounced off a Dortmund player, went between Lescott's feet to new-boy Lewandowski who promptly despatched it into the back of the net pretty well unopposed, with Zabaleta unable to recover in time.

So a 3-1 defeat and most of it our own fault. Barry for me looked as if he was still at the World Cup and although Toure Yaya did display some destructive qualities along with some fine passing, we were never creative enough from a four-man midfield and the front men did very little. Dortmund knew our strengths would be wide-out but loaded those positions leaving SWP & Johnson with little space. The only replacement to make any real difference was of course Bellamy who injected some pace, upset a few people and looked likely to make something happen. At centre back, Kompany probably looked best.

We move on to meet Valencia on Saturday evening when hopefully we should see Tevez and Silva in action and get closer to what Mancini believes will be a starting line-up for the Premier League a week later.




Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!



Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

The journalist

Writer: Tranmere Loyal Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Thursday August 5 2010

Time: 8:00AM

Your Comments (oldest first)

Change to most recent first
Cue the Everton trolls and the like. Disappointing pre-season but excluding beating Barca last time, no worse than the last pre-season that led to us making a storming start in the PL. The two new signings we've seen, Kolarov and Yaya Toure, seem a class above the others in their vicinity on the pitch. It's almost surreal how much better Kolarov is than Bridge. It's like the gap between a Premier League player and a League 1 player. Yaya and Kolarov were our best players yesterday. Barry was abysmal. Hart 7, Micah 5, Kompany 5, Kolo Toure 5, Kolarov 8, Yaya Toure 7.5, Barry 3, Johnson 6, Shauny 6.5, Jo 6, Adebayor 5
StuMCFC
Report Abuse
05/08/2010 09:25:00

OH NO! DOOM - GLOOM. We're all goint to hell in a hand basket. Perhaps next preseason we'll stay closer to home and play teams like Norwich so we can all boast about our easy wins rather than being forced to comment on which of the 17 players used (in the absence of our manager) is good enough to make tthe starting 11 at Spurs?
fifthcolumnblue
Report Abuse
05/08/2010 09:56:00

Dont worry guys, only 3 more months and the winter market will be open, then you can you can buy your missing 2 world class defenders and start "developing" new team, until then you will have to play football. Pity you actually cant.
stetos2000
Report Abuse
05/08/2010 12:32:00

Who do you support stetos?
StuMCFC
Report Abuse
05/08/2010 13:33:00

Not good enough. Im now know for sure that spurs will beat us 2-1 or 3-1. Im being relaistic and honest, citys defence and pre season preparation has been a diasaster. The squad isnt used to being away for such a long period of time and the world cup has messed up team building. Mancini hasnt been present for the recent matches, but i expect better results and performances with one away from the start of the new season. Only jo is grasping the opportunity with both hands, but ireland, richards, viera, bridge, toure and lescott seem happy to just plod around the pitch at 2mph. The defence still looks a shambles, toure and lesctott should be sold. How can city drop toure now when we have signed his much better brother. Imagine the tension that ill cause now. I would be happy if kolo was sold and yaya didnt come (though i rate yaya very highly) I hope boateng and kompany play together asap. At this rate id be happy with top 6 finish.
Super City Slicker
Report Abuse
05/08/2010 13:51:00

Agree with Stu - Kolarov and Yaya Toure look class additions to the side.
Thaibluefan
Report Abuse
05/08/2010 14:03:00

Hey I support Everton but I'm not a troll :) and Stetos is also a Toffee, ha! With Willy and other abusing us all summer you can hardly complain if a few Toffees take joy in a bad result for City, but thanks for the award!
Vanilla Ice
Report Abuse
05/08/2010 14:31:00

My pleasure Vanilla Ice ............has it been all summer ..........seems like yesterday
Wswilly3
Report Abuse
05/08/2010 14:34:00

It was yesterday... and the day before... and the day before :)
Vanilla Ice
Report Abuse
05/08/2010 15:03:00

XD 3-1, need I say more
Rob-EFC
Report Abuse
05/08/2010 15:20:00

I see there was nothing more needed to be said Rob, ha!
vanilla ice
Report Abuse
06/08/2010 15:41:00

 

Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Manchester City Articles

Man City - FSF's May Newsletter (Friday May 29 2015)

Dynamo Cancelled (Friday May 29 2015)

Toronto 0-1 Manchester City (Thursday May 28 2015)

Toure & Toronto (Wednesday May 27 2015)

Audio - Pellegrini On Toure (Wednesday May 27 2015)

Infographic - Aguero In Alternate XI (Wednesday May 27 2015)

Jake's Southampton Report (Tuesday May 26 2015)

Aguero's Surprise Inclusion (Tuesday May 26 2015)

Toure Will See Out His Contract (Monday May 25 2015)

Archived Manchester City Articles

List All VMC Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites

Vital Members League (view all)

1. Johnny Baguette 533
2. Bluedub 283
3. Buzz Lightyear 222
4. Skoorb 193
5. citizhun 162
6. OziMan 142
7. Colin Is The King 128
8. CITYBOY1000 128
9. kennyclementstache 121
10. fifthcolumnblue 81

League Results (view all)

Latest Results
Man City 2 - 0 Southampton
Swansea 2 - 4 Man City
Man City 6 - 0 Q.P.R.
Spurs 0 - 1 Man City
Man City 3 - 2 Aston Villa
Man City 2 - 0 West Ham

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
1. Chelsea 38 26 9 3 +41 87
2. Man City 38 24 7 7 +45 79
3. Arsenal 38 22 9 7 +35 75
4. Man Utd 38 20 10 8 +25 70
5. Spurs 38 19 7 12 +5 64
6. Liverpool 38 18 8 12 +4 62
7. Southampton 38 18 6 14 +21 60

Breaking League News

Diego Costa in Another Injury Scare!
Chelsea : 29/05/2015 18:57:01
Atsu Joins Bournemouth
Chelsea : 29/05/2015 18:49:01
Hendon Pens Two-Year Orient Deal
West Ham : 29/05/2015 18:40:01
United Swooping for French Teenager
Man Utd : 29/05/2015 18:32:00
Is De Boer Our Man?
West Ham : 29/05/2015 18:25:01

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Which Was Your Favourite Win From City's 18 Point Bagging Run-in?
Suggested By:  Shaun Gloater
West Ham 2-0 7%
Villa 3-2 8%
Spurs 0-1 16%
QPR 6-0 4%
Swansea 2-4 45%
Southampton 2-0 20%