Vital Football

Latest Manchester City News

Atmosphere Versus Morals

Atmosphere Versus Morals

Vital Manchester City received the following from Nick.

In the past couple of weeks, especially since the FA Cup semi-final victory against Manchester United, there has been a lot of focus on the Manchester City fans regarding the songs they sing. Opinions from people such as Mike Summerbee and Colin Bell, have raised the issue that it is 'sick' for City fans to chant songs about the Munich air disaster.

The argument states that it is disrespectful for fans to chant songs and express delight about such a devastating event. An event that on 6th February 1958 saw 23 out of the 44 people on board, die in a tragic plane crash, including 8 Manchester United players from the 'Busby Babes' and three of their backroom staff. Since then, a number of songs have emerged and it is now common knowledge amongst City fans to refer to a Manchester United supporter as 'A Munich'.

It's hard to imagine that if fans were directly face to face with the family members of those involved, that they would behave in such a manner. Yet surrounded by 30,000 other fans, they seem to think it is acceptable to get involved in these sickly taunts. It all seems a bit cowardly to me. So it begs the question of why do fans sing such harmful songs?

After all it is not just Manchester City fans that can be heard singing about tragic events. Manchester United fans themselves have been criticised in the past for chanting things such as 'murders' to Liverpool fans in reference to the Hillsborough disaster. Also, there were many songs sung about Marc Vivien-Foe following his sudden and tragic death in June 2003. So to point the blame completely at City fans is quite a naive way to view the situation.

It seems to me that this is just a case of fans chanting anything they can think of, in order to get a reaction from opposition fans. Lets face it, football fans up and down the country pay their money to attend games every week, in order to get a piece of the atmosphere, and there is no better atmosphere than when two sets of fans begin a 'chant off'.

It's the reason fans pay money to go, instead of watching the game on television. A fantastic example of this at Manchester City was highlighted earlier this season. During a game against Fulham in the Premier League at the City of Manchester Stadium, following an extremely poor turn out by the away crowd, resulting in a lack of atmosphere. The City fans then began to turn on themselves. All in good nature, the fans began to banter in each other, mainly between the south stand and the east stand. The atmosphere was fantastic and it resulted in a chant off and a little competition of who could do the best 'Poznan Dance'.

The question is, when fans chant about disasters, are they taking it too far? And if so, what can be done about it?

But then this would be such an impossible thing to police. For example, where do you draw the line on what you can sing about? Is it wrong to sing about the Munich air disaster, but ok to chant that 'Steve Bruce is the elephant man'?

Is it not a man's right, after spending all week grafting hard at work, to be able to go to the football, and let off steam by chanting football songs and releasing any built up aggression.

This issue goes further than football as well, as to what is acceptable to say in the country that brags a freedom of speech. Only the other day I was listening to the radio and heard the words 'Whips' and 'Chains' removed from Rihanna's new song to make it eligible for radio exposure. Is it just a case of political correctness taking over again?

The fact seems to be that the more people you are offending, the more immoral you are seen to be.

To try and remove these chants from the terraces, I think you would have to put a large emphasis on stewarding. Asking stewards to remove anyone seen to be breaking the rules and singing horrible songs. But to do this, firstly, it would have to be decided as to which songs are acceptable and which songs are not. With this, there can be no grey area. That is one of the reasons that racism was an easier thing to be removed. A straight forward, clear rule stating 'Kick Racism Out Of Football'!

Football has worked very hard with amazing success over the past few decades to cut racism out of the game. In England it is almost non existent in the terraces nowadays. This is not always the case abroad however. But if racism can be banished, is it possible to remove such chants surrounding awful events? Would we want to risk losing that match day with and football banter?

Thanks Nick.





Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Writer:danielqpr
Date:Thursday May 12 2011
Time: 11:39AM

Comments

0
Good article Nick, and a fair question to boot. First up I want to say for any football fan of any club to chant or goad opposition fans about any disaster, be it Munich, Heysel or Hillsborough is disgraceful. However I have read/heard many a compelling argument as to why the recent Yaya Toure chant was not singing directly about the Munich air disaster, the word Munich is used as a reference to Man United not in relation to the disaster itself but in relation to the fact that Utd gained global recognition from the event which in turn led to them being the massive global brand they are today. There are of course the idiots at every club that use these disasters to goad opposition fans but in the main I think the majority join in with the chants and don't give the term Munich a second thought as they've always commonly referred to Utd and their fans in this way. Whatever the case or the reasons for the chants the fact that the club has come out and said these chants should stop should see an end to them, the club's wishes should be respected by the fans.
bluedub
12/05/2011 13:06:00
0
I think we've lost the battle on the Munich chants - even if the term is not meant to insult the dead or mock the air disaster, it is an exceptionally emotive subject, particularly for those fans of both City and united who are old enough to remember the event. We cannot justify the chanting, and even if it is not meant to belittle the dead, it sounds like we're doing just that. I've always hated the term munich, and when it comes to something to scan in the songs, I always substitute the term "red scum", as in the Ryan Giggs song: "He's a red scum ********". It really is time to stop the Munich chants and move on. We're bigger than that, and we're better than them. Singing munich songs is just sinking to their level.
fifthcolumnblue
12/05/2011 21:55:00
Page 1/1
  1. 1

Login to post a comment

Recent Manchester City Articles

Red Card Report 2017 - The Chinese Market

The sixth edition of the Red Card report into how European clubs fare in the Chinese fan market has now been released.

The Manchester City Walking Wounded - Injury Table

Our weekly update looking at the injury table for Manchester City and also comparing with all our competitors in the Premier League.

FA Cup Quarter Finals Get 4th Sub

Football Association chief executive Martin Glenn has confirmed that those clubs involved in this year's Quarter Finals of the FA Cup will get a fourth substitute...

BT Sport Show Boro v Man City / Huddersfield FA Cup Tie

If Manchester City overcome Championship side Huddersfield Town on Wednesday, 1 March (BBC One - kick off 19:45 GMT) in the FA Fifth Round replay then Blues unable...

Archived VMC Articles

VMC articles from

Site Journalists

Tudor (VMC Editor)
Editor email
Profile
Johnny Baguette
no email
Profile
Pedmachine
no email
Profile
Skoorb
no email
Profile

Current Poll (see more polls)

With City not playing this weekend which live English TV game will you watch?
Suggested By: Tudor
Leeds v Sheffield Wednesday (Sky)1%
Brighton v Reading (Sky)0%
Norwich v Ipswich (Sky)0%
Spuds v Stoke (Sky)0%
Saints v Rags (EPL Cup Final - Sky)9%
Watford v West Ham (BT)0%
Two of the above0%
Three of the above9%
Four of the above0%
Five of the above0%
All six0%
I won't watch any81%
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites

League Table

# Team P W D L Pts. GD
1 Chelsea 25 19 3 3 60 34
2 Man City 25 16 4 5 52 22
3 Spurs 25 14 8 3 50 28
4 Arsenal 25 15 5 5 50 26
5 Liverpool 25 14 7 4 49 24
6 Man Utd 25 13 9 3 48 17
7 Everton 25 11 8 6 41 13
8 WBA 25 10 7 8 37 3
9 Stoke 25 8 8 9 32 -6
10 West Ham 25 9 5 11 32 -9
11 Southampton 25 8 6 11 30 -3
12 Burnley 25 9 3 13 30 -9
13 Watford 25 8 6 11 30 -13
14 AFC Bournemouth 25 7 5 13 26 -14
15 Swansea 25 7 3 15 24 -23
16 Middlesbrough 25 4 10 11 22 -8
17 Leicester City 25 5 6 14 21 -19
18 Hull City 25 5 5 15 20 -27
19 Crystal Palace 25 5 4 16 19 -14
20 Sunderland 25 5 4 16 19 -22
The Vital Football Members League
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
Vital Football Comment

Recent Manchester City Results (view all)

Manchester City Fixtures (view all)

Feb 26 2017 2:15PM : Manchester United (H)
Barclays Premier League
Mar 5 2017 4:00PM : Sunderland (a)
Barclays Premier League
Mar 11 2017 12:30PM : Stoke City (H)
Barclays Premier League
Mar 19 2017 4:30PM : Liverpool (H)
Barclays Premier League
Apr 1 2017 3:00PM : Arsenal (a)
Barclays Premier League
Apr 5 2017 7:45PM : Chelsea (a)
Barclays Premier League

Vital Members League Table

RankNamePoints
1.Buzz Lightyear554
2.Skoorb268
3.Johnny Baguette256
4.Rising142
5.Bluedub123
6.Tudor107
7.johnkelv106
8.citizhun77
9.Colin Is The King74
10.kennyclementstache59
Write for Vital Football