Manchester City - The Ped Report: City 2-3 United
UK time is: 08:40:56
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

The Ped Report: City 2-3 United

It is with some bewilderment that the Pedmachine writes his report this morning. At 6am and with rain lashing in on the North Car Park, the Blue Mooners set off on another pilgrimage to the National Stadium in a positive frame of mind. The pre-season was going well, we had already beaten you-know-who on the hallowed turf, so it was looking like new 'business as usual.' What was about to unfold left us puzzled, mesmerised and tearing our hair out. If indeed we have any left! And today this true blue will hand out bouquets to the club he dislikes and brickbats to his own boys.

Meaningless friendly? No. Unimportant trophy? No. United got into their stride quickly to show that they meant business.

Mancini set City up to play essentially 4-4-2 but with the fluidity to change to 4-5-1, 4-3-3 or even the Keegan-killing 3-5-2, more or less at will.

The problem was either the will wasn't there or it was a far too intricate set of instructions to send out for a match of this magnitude.

Milner was selected ahead of Barry. This was designed to allow him either to tuck in alongside de Jong and allow Richards to overlap, or to play wide right. He never really got to grips with either role.

On the other side, Balotelli or Dzeko were to provide the extra man in midfield when we were without the ball, but also allowed Kolarov to be the wide left option.

This all proved far too confusing as United with their crisp, accurate, pass and move game plan, time and again carved City open, their only major shortcoming being a lack of threat in the forwards.

Young, with smart passing from Rooney often got into the space behind Richards, stretching the City backline, and Nani was doing likewise on the other side.

It is not always the forward penetration that ulitmately wins matches. We have seen at City how lateral work can be just as important when applied by the tireless Tevez. Today Rooney replicated that for United. Still sore at having been suspended from the now historic semi final, he elected to take this game by the scruff of the neck in a way that no City player was capable of yesterday.

So with the possession stats looking at 70:30 United it was somewhat surprising that on 38 minutes a pinpoint freekick from the Wizard of the Etihad found Lescott unmarked between the United defensive stalwarts of Vidic and Ferdinand, and he headed home as de Gea waited just behind him to collect.

It puzzled us even further that, just ahead of the break, Vidic backed off from Dzeko, leaving him in acres of space and with time to drill a powerful shot not really into the bottom corner but still far enough away from the lumbering de Gea, who in fairness should have done better.

So half time, City not in any kind of stride , being played off the park and winning 2-0. Extraordinary.

Mancini clearly thought the game was in the bag and despite having the availability to field up to 6 replacements he sent the same team out for the second half. After all they only had to go through the motions...didn't they?

For his part, Ferguson made brave and determined substitutions. Vidic and Ferdinand were hauled off for youngsters Jones and Evans and the ineffective Carrick was replaced by Cleverley. Their instructions couldn't have been clearer - 'You are the boys who have won nothing. Go out and make a name for yourself'. And didn't they just do that?

Straight down to business. Pass and move, pass and move. Find a red shirt.

City were clearly handicapped by the procession of early yellow cards meted out by Phil Dowd. United were in determined mood to keep the ball and to see what they could prize out of the match. There was no panic. They pressed from higher up the field and with Milner annonymous, Balotelli ineffective, Richards and Kolarov pinned back, Silva unable to find space, the midfield effort was left to de Jong, solo.

A free kick from Young in almost an identical location to that served up by Silva earlier brought the same result. As the ball looked destined to reach Joe Hart, and with Kompany and Lescott static, Smalling nipped in to divert the cross into the net.

And if City can score twice in eight minutes, don't you think that United can do the same. Yes afraid so. And when it came it was a dream goal.

It was a simply brilliant move. De Jong for once missed a tackle some forty yards from goal and from then United set in motion a move which involved no less than four United players and eight quick-fire first time passes which left City's defence looking like a set of wheelie bins. A surgeon with a scalpel couldn't carve open a cadaver as fast. Cleverley's clever back heel finally wrong footed the wheelies leaving Nani wide open eight yards out and Joe Hart was once again collecting the ball out of the back of the net.

Mancini finally decided it was time to replace Balotelli. But for some reason this was with Barry and not the man the fans wanted to see...Sergio Aguero. Barry was clearly told to provide more resistance in midfield, to stop de Jong being swamped by United's effervescence. Even the lumbering and overweight Anderson was starting to look like a world beater! Mancini had settled for penalties.

After an hour it looked like City had brought some order back to their lives and Milner at last made way for Johnson. He immediately livened things up to the extent that Evra, never happy when challenged was replaced by one of those twins. I'm not sure Fergie knew which one. He was designed to renew the energy down United's left but found himself the victim of some good work by Johnson before he got to the pace of the game. One such moment saw Johnson leave him for dead and unleash a screamer that was goalbound until de Gea finally actually saved something and a decisive save it was.

Dzeko was granted a chance from a pass by Yaya but got it tangled in his feet and couldn't get a 'big' strike away and that was all City had in the locker....until that dreaded moment came along, once again in Fergie time.

Mancini had elected not to treat the fans to a glimpse of Aguero and the only additional change he made was to bring on Clichy for Kolarov. And this was to prove to be the match winner. Sadly though not for City. As Fergie wisely brought on Berbatov for the penalty shoot out, Clichy had other ideas. After all, he is ex-Arsenal isn't he, so why not bring some Ashburton Comedy to the Community Shield?

With City making a last throw of the dice United punted the ball clear. There was no danger, Kompany and Clichy we in attendance weren't they? Well yes they were and what was about to unfold was delivered straight out of Arsene Wenger's new tactical aid to not winning a trophy. Clichy went for the ball, Kompany backed off, then Clichy left it
and it bounced past Kompany and into the clear. As you would expect from United, somebody was gambling and this time it was Nani who immediately set off for goal, drew Hart, dummied, stepped clear and sent the southern Stretfords into raptures long before he even fired the ball into the attendant empty net. Truly game over.

Much was learned from this debacle and much was shown not to have been learned from previous encounters.

For Mancini, he clearly has to understand that United are dead and buried after 96 minutes when the final whistle blows and the scoreboard shows that they have conceded more goals than they have scored. It is not over at half time just because you are winning 2-0. Also you have to use your substitutes in order to try to change match outcomes. Fergie was brave, Mancini nonsensical. Why pay £38m for one of the world's best players and leave him on the bench? I'm sure that's what Khaldoon had in mind when he questioned Mancini at the end of the match.

He has identified that we need an effective midfielder to supplement de Jong and complement Silva. OK. Cut to the chase. Get Tevez by the ear and get on the Ryanair to Malpensa. You are not going to get £50m for Tevez so trade him for Sneijder. Straight swap, no nonsense, no cost. Then get Nasri for £18m and top it off with Mata for something similar.

I have said before that if you buy Villa players the best you get is players that finished sixth. If you want to move forward, you need players of better quality. I have listed them for you, you already know who they are. Barry has now had his time, and Milner has had enough time to show the blue and white world that he is not good enough.

For was business as usual, and for a while he has silenced his Noisy Neighbours.

all times GMT+1

Mo 15 Aug 20:00 Swansea, Etihad Stadium, PL
Su 21 Aug 16:00 Bolton, Reebok Stadium, PL
Su 28 Aug 13:30 Spurs, White Hart Lane, PL


Join the debate in the VMC City Chat Forum as we gear up for the big Premier League kick off!


VMC is now available on both Facebook and Twitter, so if you are that way inclined and more importantly understand all this new fangled dangled stuff, feel free to watch us, poke us or whatever else you are meant to do there!

VMC on: facebook

VMC on: twitter


It's easy to REGISTER HERE, simply click the link and enjoy getting involved!

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

The journalist

Writer: Tranmere Loyal Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Monday August 8 2011

Time: 11:00AM

Your Comments (oldest first)

Change to most recent first
Bang on the money this report.
Johnny Baguette
Report Abuse
08/08/2011 11:18:00

When did U*d carve us open? Nani's goal aside ( when De Jong went asleep ) I don't recall them carving us open. They were sharper, fitter and more determined but I think your being a bit overgenerous in your bouquet throwing Ped.
Report Abuse
08/08/2011 11:23:00

I still maintain that we made them look good by not pressing them at all. I think that's what Ped's driving at dubster.
Johnny Baguette
Report Abuse
08/08/2011 11:26:00

Dub, there were several times when they got into space behind our full backs through quick decisive passing, similar in some ways to the goal we scored against Stoke. These may at times have been wide out, but if they'd had better forwards, they'd have made more of it. The goal was aculmination of it all coming together. As JB says the comparison was Milner joining the the idea of quick crisp a red shirt... and inviting them back on offense. Then with Richards and Kolarov often further forward, the openings came along.
Report Abuse
08/08/2011 11:50:00

Fair enough Ped, I just feel they're receiving too many plaudits from that game as a whole. They deserved their win there's no doubt about that but I feel there is a massive overreaction to how well they played. For instance I don't recall Hart making a save of note in the game.
Report Abuse
08/08/2011 11:54:00

In fact, mate, discussing on the concourses at half time, there were many Blues sharing the view that we were being outplayed in midfield and even they couldn't comprehend what the scoreboard was reading..and they were the sober ones!!
Report Abuse
08/08/2011 11:54:00

Bang on Ped. No one will sway me from my opinion that Milner and Barry are *****. Why do we need them? They will be one of the main reasons Mancini falls on his sword.
Report Abuse
08/08/2011 12:55:00

Rags were very good but we didn't turn up where it mattered, in midfield. Yaya was absent, no-one passed to Silva, agree about Milner, just not good enough. Barry may not be the greatest but he will help to get us many points against so-so Prem teams. Micah still needs to run as fast tracking back as he does going forward. With Clichy and Aguero we'll be better but neither are midfielders - Yaya has to play better than that and I'm hoping for a miracle midfield transfer to come in in the next two weeks. Nice report ped.
Report Abuse
08/08/2011 14:10:00

except silva and de jong..i'm expecting you will replaced the 2nd half squad with new signings..come on!!!..three more weeks to go and still billions in the bank..heh
Report Abuse
09/08/2011 02:36:00

What's a "2nd half squad"?
Report Abuse
09/08/2011 09:46:00

What's a "2nd half squad"? ==> Man City's bunch of overrated and overpaid so called footballers playing in 2nd half vs united
Report Abuse
09/08/2011 09:56:00

Oh the team, I'm with you now. The same TEAM started the 2nd half as started the 1st. So are you saying De Jong and Silva aside that we should replace the whole team? Btw Yid, Spurs owner has billions in the bank too, where's all your signings?
Report Abuse
09/08/2011 10:00:00

Don't take the p1ss Dub, everyone knows nobody wants to sign for Spuds
Report Abuse
09/08/2011 18:11:00
Report Abuse
09/08/2011 21:21:00

Balotelli was born on August 12, 1990. He was fostered by an Italian couple after his Ghanaian parents admitted they needed help caring for him. He is a black Italian footballer who grew up in a country where racism is still very much present in the stands. He moved to a strange land when he was 19. You know all this, but it's worth mentioning again because a lot of people seem to have written him off as a liability already, convinced that whatever is currently going on in his head will preclude him from making a success of his career. This is becoming a minor pet project of mine, but in both his performance in, and interview after the FA Cup final, Balotelli displayed a good degree of maturity and self-awareness - two qualities he will need in order to thrive. But if Balotelli continues behaving as he has been for another season, it will be significantly more difficult for me to continue arguing as I have been. Finding out whether he is capable of mending his ways is certainly going to be interesting.
Report Abuse
09/08/2011 21:23:00

The Premier League tends to export superstars, rather than buy them. And for all the millions and millions Manchester City spent before this summer, they hadn't tempted a genuine superstar to these shores. Balotelli was (and still is) raw promise, Edin Dzeko had two decent seasons under his belt, Yaya Toure spent most of his time at Barcelona carrying water for Xavi and Iniesta, and David Silva had a healthy reputation but wasn't a first choice for Spain. Aguero was coveted by more or less every serious club on the continent and City, through the number of noughts on his contract or perhaps by taking him to the Imperial War Museum North, got him. How they will actually use him will be a concern for Roberto Mancini and City fans - the rest of us are simply looking forward to one of the world's best players appearing on our televisions each week.
Report Abuse
09/08/2011 21:26:00

Bluemillionaire - when you're quoting someone may I suggest you use quotation marks. And why are you quoting articles from Football365? What exactly is your point?
Report Abuse
10/08/2011 08:48:00

At half time I told my mate there aint no way we will concede 3 in the second half, and we did. This will only make us stronger this season. Utd will not make top 4.
Report Abuse
10/08/2011 10:21:00

Flawless logic there johnkelv.
Report Abuse
12/08/2011 07:20:00

So glad you approve Delta.
Report Abuse
12/08/2011 18:01:00


Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Manchester City Articles

Stats: Juventus v Manchester City (Wednesday November 25 2015)

Juventus v Man City - Teamsheets! (Wednesday November 25 2015)

Aguero & Toure Ahead Of Juventus (Tuesday November 24 2015)

Aguero Sets New Record (Monday November 23 2015)

Pellegrini On Liverpool Disaster (Sunday November 22 2015)

Stats: Manchester City v Liverpool (Saturday November 21 2015)

Man City v Liverpool - Team Line Ups (Saturday November 21 2015)

Archived Manchester City Articles

List All VMC Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites

Vital Members League (view all)

League Results (view all)

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
1. Leicester City 13 8 4 1 +8 28
2. Man Utd 13 8 3 2 +10 27
3. Man City 13 8 2 3 +14 26
4. Arsenal 13 8 2 3 +12 26
5. Spurs 13 6 6 1 +13 24
6. West Ham 13 6 3 4 +4 21
7. Everton 13 5 5 3 +8 20

Manchester City Fixtures (view all)

Breaking League News

Qarabag vs Tottenham Hotspur.
Spurs : 26/11/2015 08:37:00
Manchester United 0 PSV Eindhoven 0
Man Utd : 26/11/2015 07:39:00
Man Utd : 26/11/2015 07:23:01
Nicholas Nkoulou On The Radar?
Norwich : 26/11/2015 07:22:00
Thompson The Match Winner
Norwich : 26/11/2015 07:00:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

CL - Juventus MotM
Suggested By:  Site Staff
Hart 0%
Sagna 0%
Demichelis 0%
Otamendi 0%
Clichy 0%
Fernando 0%
Fernandinho 0%
Jesus Navas 0%
Toure 0%
De Bruyne 0%
Aguero 0%
Sub - Delph 0%
Sub - Sterling 0%
Sub - Caballero 0%