UK time is: 04:44:40
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

The Ped Report City 0-1 Liverpool

Liverpool took a major step towards Wembley Way as the Manchester rain once again crumbled the very foundations of Fortress Etihad for the second time in four days.

After the debacle against Stretford`s finest saw City surrender their grip on the long awaited FA Cup, their passage to another final looks seriously in doubt as Liverpool, learning from their errors of last week scored and then shut up shop against a City side playing more in the fashion of the Mark Hughes era than in the Mancini/Platt scenario.

Once again it poured down, but tonight with a makeshift team shorn of Yaya Toure, absent at the African Cup of Nations, Silva rested through injury and Kompany rested courtesy of a poor referees decision on Sunday and an even poorer FA decision yesterday, City looked far from being at the races.

Liverpool lined up in a solid 4-5-1 intent on winning any midfield battles with the ineffective Carroll ploughing a lone trough up front although he was supported quickly and in typical fashion by Gerrard.

City trying a 4-4-2 formation were simply over ran in midfield and found all the doors locked.

From the off Liverpool got on the front foot to the extent that it was 42 minutes before City had what could be called a shot on goal. Three times Hart was called upon to make quality saves to keep the scoreboard vacant.

Neat Liverpool passing at the edge of the box put Carroll totally clear, but he is out of confidence and out of style as he failed to bet Hart one-on-one. Great save, Joe. Next up Gerrard fired in one of his trade mark curlers from the edge of the box which was going in by the far post and Hart hurled himself across his goal to make an excellent save. From the resultant corner another shot went in, same time, same place, same ending.

At the fourth time of asking, City defending once again in kami-kaze style found Savic tackling high giving the referee what is becoming a gleeful task in pointing to the spot.

Gerrard, having tested Hart to his left, tried his luck to the right and his shot was just good enough to evade Joe`s brave dive and creep in by the post.

This was job done for Liverpool as they starved City of the ball for much of the first half, forcing City to battle in midfield and leave Aguero and Balotelli stranded unsupported upfield.

Balotelli was clearly unfit for purpose today and when he stubbed his toe taking a free kick and ricked his damaged ankle that was the end of his night, and indeed before half time.

Liverpool easily saw the first half out not intent on introducing any danger. For their part City only huffed and puffed but couldn`t find anything to blow the house down.

Reshaping for the second half brought more intent from City but without Silva and Yaya there was nobody really showing for the ball and on occasion City looked flat-footed. Johnson was totally ineffective, Barry not his usual self and Milner tried hard but delivered not much.

City`s threat seemed to be coming from Richard and Clichy but ended generally without height and strength in the box where Aguero was lively but adequately marshalled by Skrtl and Agger. Liverpool still dominated centre midfield forcing City around the outside where they did get some joy but time and again the cross had no Dzeko or Balotelli on the end of it and was laid to waste.

Aguero worked astonishingly hard to try to carve out openings but it just didn`t happen for City tonight. Liverpool eased to a 1-0 victory having learned considerably from their defeat last week. Having said that they still did not threaten at all after the opening period but defended their lead effectively.

Carroll was terrible. Downing not much better. Henderson worked hard in midfield and when he came off for the injured Spearing, Adam went about his usual work kicking anything that moved except the ball. Just what does he deliver to the Liverpool team? Their back line looked in control even though Johnson was playing at left back to keep him out of the way of Clichy who slaughtered him last week.

From City`s viewpoint, the back line looked reasonably sound after the opening onslaught. Balotelli looked as if he wanted to be elsewhere and Aguero grafted as he does every time he pulls on the shirt.

It was in midfield where the match was won and lost. City did not overcome Liverpool`s crowding out of the centre and their blocking of the channels. Barry and Milner played like they did for Aston Villa and that`s how it played out for City. Gone was the guile, craft and magic of Silva, gone was the enforcement of Yaya. Instead we were left with simply a shadow of a midfield that promises a lot but doesn`t deliver. When he came on he may have tried hard but Nasri is not Silva. When he came on Dzeko did practically nothing, essentially joining Carroll on the lack of confidence and run the wrong channel bench.

Joe Hart was simply Joe Hart, fast becoming the world`s best goalkeeper. There isn`t a better one in the Premier League and why the likes of FIFA continually set their stall out with Iker Casillas astonishes me. Like the David Seaman of old he rarely sees the ball at Real Madrid.

This match highlights the fact that City might have in theory a large squad but like all teams, lose your best three and you struggle. The replacements are easier to suss out as they do not play with any serious threat, they play to a system that is now alien to City, but is more in keeping with a traditional team with traditional players.

It is time Nasri took games by the scruff of the neck, that Milner followed through his promise and graft, that Johnson stopped flattering to deceive. That leaves us Nigel de Jong, a cornerstone of the success that City enjoyed last season and an unsung hero in my view in the FA Cup Final. This season, starved of matches he looks well off the pace and a mile away from what City fans expect from him. Sadly tonight I though he took away some of the balance in the team and didn`t contribute anything really positive. Maybe the influences of a car salesman are creeping in. We could in reality have gone two at the back with de Jong shielding as he did at Wembley, such was the forward threat offered by Liverpool. This would have made City able to match Liverpool in midfield and still have men over up top, but Platty didn`t come up with that one.

We are now left with two options. Either we take the Arsenal route to oblivion by getting knocked out of everything in quick tempo, or Mancini and Platt get the tactics right at Anfield where an early City goal puts the cat amongst the pigeons and another early Liverpool goal ends the tie. It is worrying that in two cup matches we have given up early goals to the opposition. Or we go for it, get the equaliser and get at them down the channels. To achieve this we cannot field injured footballers as we did tonight and we must play the Magician himself.

With Spurs having won tonight, by the time we play Wigan they plus you-know-who could both be level with us on points making a routine match one of a pressing nature. Then Spurs come to us. It is already sold out. What a mouthwatering prospect.




Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!



Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

The journalist

Writer: Tranmere Loyal Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Thursday January 12 2012

Time: 9:00AM

Your Comments

Spot on Ped. I want to know why we started with a whimper instead of a fight? The resilient spirit we showed in the second half on Sunday should have been harnessed and brought into this one, instead it was the complete opposite, we were powder puff.
Bluedub
Milner and Aguero were running on empty, plain and simple. After they ran their hearts out for 80 minutes against the rags, we all hailed them as heroes, and righfully so - but to ask them both to put in another huge shift only 3 days later against a much fresher and well rested Liverpool side was always going to be a big ask. Combine that with a shaky defence and players who haven't had that much time on the pitch this season and you get what we saw last night - a disjointed, lethargic performance. Undoubtedly we missed Yaya Sliva and Kompany and that showed, but this tie is far from over, and the scousers had six defenders on the pitch at the end, such was their desparation to cling onto a 1-nil lead. This tie is far from over, and on our second half performance I'd have to say I quite fancy our chances of turning it around at Anfield, regardless of whatever idiot the FA decide to allow to officiate the match.
fifthcolumnblue
Of course we can beat them in the return leg, even with the players we have missing we are a better side. The attitude has to be right from the start at Anfield if we have any chance, start like we did last night and we might as well just lay down and accept not getting to Wembley.
Bluedub
Absolutely pathetic attendance last night. It's embarrassing to be a blue when it's the semi-final, our home advantage, half the country is watching and we can't even half fill the stadium. Liverpool were one man up from the start.
SkyBlueSuedeShoes
I think you are gonna get dumped out of this as well - is your rot setting in at the golden pot that is the Etihad?
niteworlok
It's more rotten at the Swamp, Balckburn? PMSL!
Bluedub
Scholes? No value in the market!
fifthcolumnblue
Niteworlok, you have misspelled 'hope'. Always re-check for spelling and grammar mistakes before posting on VMC. Thanks
rojo2010
Has to be said, the Ped Report outclasses the majority of match reports in The Street of Shame. Only Martin Samuel offers similar balance imho.
Johnny Baguette
How have I mispelled hope? Not even used it in my reply - I said POT - so rojo - get yer facts right :P
niteworlok
You did spell it wrong NW it's not t.h.i.n.k it's h.o.p.e.
Bluedub
We are not the same team without Yaya and Silva. Kompany can be covered for barely I think but Yaya and Silva are so important. Nasri looked quite good and if the players around him hadn't been so lifeless he might have been something of a useful Silva Jr., but we simply have no one with Yaya's presence and ability. If we can somehow pull off the De Rossi deal (difficult but the club are trying) then that problem would be solved. The thought of De Rossi and Yaya together in the same midfield gives me goosebumps.
StuMCFC
Thanks for the explanation B'Dub... ;)
rojo2010
I dont 'hope' the rot has set in - i 'KNOW' its setting in
niteworlok
 

Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Manchester City Articles

City Lose To Liverpool On Penalties (Thursday July 31 2014)

Proving Your Point (Tuesday July 29 2014)

Jovetic Takes Chance To Impress (Monday July 28 2014)

City Not Feeling Charitable (Sunday July 27 2014)

City Win Meeting Of Champions (Thursday July 24 2014)

Negredo Undergoes Surgery (Wednesday July 23 2014)

U21 Game Cancelled - Club Statement (Wednesday July 23 2014)

Negredo Replacement Targeted (Wednesday July 23 2014)

Archived Manchester City Articles

List All VMC Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

League Results (view all)

Latest Results

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
7. Hull City 0 0 0 0 0 0
8. Leicester City 0 0 0 0 0 0
9. Liverpool 0 0 0 0 0 0
10. Man City 0 0 0 0 0 0
11. Man Utd 0 0 0 0 0 0
12. Newcastle 0 0 0 0 0 0
13. Q.P.R. 0 0 0 0 0 0

Breaking League News

Bojan Gets Squad Number
Stoke : 31/07/2014 21:46:00
Arsenal Fan Goes Out On Loan
Arsenal : 31/07/2014 21:30:00
Danny: Champion of the World!
Spurs : 31/07/2014 21:10:00
Albion Announce 2014-15 Squad Numbers
WBA : 31/07/2014 18:13:00
Bertrand Joins On Season Long Loan
Southampton : 31/07/2014 18:02:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Player of the Year?
Suggested By:  Site Staff
David Silva 8%
Pablo Zabaleta 42%
Edin Dzeko 5%
Yaya Toure 45%