Manchester City - The Ped Report Liverpool 2-2 City
UK time is: 10:09:37
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

The Ped Report Liverpool 2-2 City

Football`s gods once again lined-up for the opposition last night at Anfield Stadium, where City needed to reverse a home defeat to progress to what would have been their second Wembley final in two seasons.

As Sunday`s referee fudged a decision he had already made using the Wenger-esque "I didn`t see it", despite the fact that he was looking straight at the Balotelli incident, last night`s joker produced a penalty for Liverpool that was simply laughable and which ultimately sentenced City to concentrating on the League…oh and the Europa League also.

Liverpool took the game to City from the off in similar fashion to their production at the Etihad. Their shoot on sight policy was designed, hopefully, create problems in a defence shorn of Kompany for the last time and to an extent it worked.

The result was an extraordinary performance by Joe Hart, for me the world`s best goalkeeper.

City were tidy on the ball but for the first half hour didn`t really threaten, whereas Hart had to fend off Adam, Gerrard and Enrique with astonishing saves as well as facing the constant threat from the buzzing Bellamy.

So it could be said to have been against the run of play when, on the half hour, of all people de Jong found himself in space 25 yards out and curling a peach around Reina and into the Liverpool net. Cue the Poznan.

But City never really looked comfortable at the back and the formation of playing Richards, Savic and Lescott as a back three, guarded by de Jong, I think was a result of the frailties that we have seen from Savic. Every match he has played has been a "big one" and it is to his credit that he put in the shifts, but Kompany he is not and although I do have praise for the lad, I hope Mancini does not consign him to the recycle bin as he has done with Boyata and also Onuoha.

And then came another moment of arbitration magic form probably the biggest IFP referee of them all. I will remind you that IFP stands for "In Fergie`s Pocket". Was it not this referee that awarded Aston Villa a first minute penalty in the Carling Cup Final 2 years ago, but failed to send off the offender, Vidic?

Where on earth did he get this decision from? If the shot at goal would have hit Richards directly on an outstretched arm, I could probably have gone with the referee, but when Richards blocks the shot with his knee and it squirts up into the air and hits his hand, then no, I don`t think so Mr Dowd. It was quite ridiculous that a shot that cannoned off the knee and was headed into the Anfield Road end should be interpreted as deliberate and therefore a penalty awarded. No red card, no yellow card tells you Dowd didn`t know what he`d given. Just as at Wembley, he chickened out.

Dalglish starts angling for Richards to be sent off. No furore there then. I wonder what would have happened if it would have been Roberto.

So once again Gerrard scores from the spot and promptly displays 2 fingers in the direction of Joe Hart. Yes it might mean he had scored 2 penalties against Joe, Gerrard would hardly ever score any other way these days, but if that had been Balotelli…….?

If City had got to half time at 1-0 it would probably have been a different story but in the light of Hart`s performance it was perhaps fitting that the only way he would be beaten was from a supercilious decision like that one.

As the second half began, Liverpool once again got into gear. City had changed to a flat back four with Savic withdrawn and Aguero pushed on up front to help Dzeko.

Liverpool were again the main threat, with Bellamy to the fore. Single handedly he kept Richards and Lescott busy, but for once were starting to get a feel for the match when after 67 minutes Kolarov got clear on the left, from a Silva pass and sent a searching ball along the Liverpool six yard line. None of the three defenders fancied getting a toe to it and it went a long way to Dzeko luring at the far post and he promptly once again levelled the tie with a typical poachers goal.

Both teams were now hunting for a winner and the game had opened out. Hart was still performing heroics having made six exceptional saves and for City Silva was working hard to get the attack moving. Aguero was starting to create problems similar to those at the other end from Bellamy and it was perhaps fitting that after 74 minutes the ex-City man exchanged passes in the box with Johnson and slotted an excellent shot at last past Hart to claim the match and a place in the final for Liverpool.

This prompted Liverpool to bring on an extra defender to see out the match and they appeared to do this with some comfort.

The talking point will undoubtedly be the penalty decision. Dowd spent so long trying to persuade everyone that outstretching your arms leaves you vulnerable to a decision like that but he had not registered the fact that every time Richards confronted a Liverpool attacker he deliberately kept his hands and arms our of the way. On the occasion of the penalty the shot was low level, so outstretching his arms was a natural thing to do as he would block the shot with his legs. Dowd knew he`s made the wrong call there and was trying to justify that decision to himself as much as the players.

t was a reasonably good performance all round by City. Savic looked a bit weak, Kolarov on more for his attacking than defending, but Zabaleta, Lescott and Richard all stayed strong, marshalled by a better effort from de Jong, who`s goal was outstanding.

Barry provided the midfield graft whilst Silva was freed to roam and move in tandem with the improving Nasri. Dzeko ploughed a lone furrow up top but was still causing Skrtl problems.

That only leaves one man…Joe Hart. This was probably the best performance in a single match by a Premier League goalkeeper this season and it is a testimony to Joe that he kept this up for three quarters of the match before he was finally beaten by a legitimate shot on goal. Joe was absolutely exceptional tonight…and he`s English.

Liverpool brickbats go to Gerrard for his antagonistic gesture. A player that I have respected throughout his career now for me falls into the Joey Barton category. Adam actually playd some football tonight although an unpunished trade mark naughty tackle from behind on Dzeko, in the penalty area, as you would expect if it is in City`s favour, wasn`t given by a very poor referee.

Plaudits must go to Craig Bellamy. Readers of the Ped Report will know that in my summaries towards the end of last season and for some of this I have championed the fact that had City retained and used Bellamy last season, they would have ended it as Champions themselves. Bellamy can make an impact, Bellamy can turn draws into wind, losses into draws. And he demonstrated last night that, despite having played 90 minutes in the whacking at Bolton over the weekend, he can still do two games in one week. He was a constant thorn in the flesh and forced Hart onto his toes. He now takes his case to Wembley needing to dispose of his home town Club, Cardiff City in what will be a traumatic affair for Bellers.

City are out of a Cup that they should have won. There is no doubt that the unsportsmanlike conduct of that despicable creature Rooney in getting Kompany red carded has cost City. With Vincent in control at the back I doubt Liverpool would have scored in this tie. I doubt that Mancini would have started Balotelli in this one anyway, but the defence was found out, with Kolo away and Vincent on suspension.

On the plus side he will be back in earnest for the next League match and with the only distraction now being the Europa League maybe City will project themselves well in the title race and get themselves over the line come May.

If they do want to progress in the Europa League they will have to smarten in two-legged football. The Pedmachine has said before, in these pages, that City have not managed the art of home and away legs. We fell against Hamburg, then against the Stretfords, then against Kyiv and now against Liverpool. The next chance to put this right is against FC Porto who are no mugs when it comes to this type of football and who will provide City, once again, with a stern continental challenge.

It is about picking the right team, but the "away" team that Mancini traditionally selects for his trips into Europe, leave me disturbed.

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

The journalist

Writer: Tranmere Loyal Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Thursday January 26 2012

Time: 11:29AM

Your Comments (oldest first)

Change to most recent first
Very disappointed with the team selection and tactics last night. I think Bobby just does not know how to play two legged games. It cost him his job and it does not augur well at City. OK we can moan at two bad refereeing decisions all we like that will not change anything. The fact is if it was not for Joe Hart last night Liverpool could have had double figures they totally dominated us.
Report Abuse
26/01/2012 11:52:00

I meant cost him his job at Inter of course
Report Abuse
26/01/2012 11:53:00

Interesting take on Mancini jackblue. We were certainly absolutely woeful in the first half of both legs and you do wonder how the players were prepared by the Management team for these CC games. We need to remind ourselves how far we've come in a short space of time that we're so disappointed about drawing 2-2 at Anfield, but it just seemed to me that the team's body language and the will to win was never there from the players over the two legs.
Report Abuse
26/01/2012 12:12:00

Agree Hart was absolutely amazing. All four times we've met this season he has been fantastic - he almost single handedly earned a point at Anfield in the league. I think we deserved to progress overall but you are right the penalty decision was a little harsh on Richards. You also had a good shout for one of your own when Adam felled Dzeko at a first half corner. Great game though! All the best for the rest of the season… Vital Liverpool match report
The Bagman
Report Abuse
26/01/2012 12:20:00

He has been brilliant our Joe but I disagree about all four times. The 3-0 at home he had little or nothing to do, spread himself to deny Downing at the start of the game and spread himself to deny Maxi at the end of the game, saves that would be expected of any half decent keeper. I couldn't believe what I was hearing from the commentator last night when he said Liverpool were unlucky in the league game at the Etihad, complete tosh.
Report Abuse
26/01/2012 12:44:00

It's been a rough five weeks with patience, and squad resources thoroughly tested. Yet City are heading out of January top of the league with a fixture list offering three very winnable games against Everton, Fulham and Aston Villa offering a chance to pull clear at the top of the league before the adventure in Porto.
Johnny Baguette
Report Abuse
26/01/2012 14:14:00

Good report Ped. Mancini got it skewed last night. Savic was proven again to be a liability, even with the added protection at the back. I feel for him in a way though, at 21yrs of age with no experience being thrown into matches against Liverpool twice, Wigan and Spurs - it's not an easy induction into Premier League life...
Report Abuse
26/01/2012 14:40:00

Joe Hart may have been your saviour last night if that ref hadn't given the penalty when he did. Also thought you should have had one given to you as well.
SFC Forever
Report Abuse
26/01/2012 14:55:00

every time we have been beaten, it has been a referee decision that has done us, penalty decisions at home to The Rags, in the FA Cup, liverpool in the 2 Carling Cup ties, a penalty in Loss at Chelsea and AN Offside decision NOT given in the loss at Sunderland, i think our luck has to change sometime, last night we played OK, and Joe Hart was MoM in my opinion, But the referee decided Liverpool would progress, With that Terrible decision, but we move on and just have to make sure we WIN the title....
Report Abuse
26/01/2012 19:00:00

I'll take the title and Champions League spot over backing into the Europa League through the CC any day of the week.
Report Abuse
26/01/2012 19:27:00

Kenny may say that Liverpool deserved it, but had the referee, see the Dzeko foul and rightly dismissed the Liverpool penalty as accidental, City could have come away with liverpool regretting their missed chances. Dowd had a nightmare and Liverpool were the better team on the night that they only drew. best of luck to them in the final.
Buzz Lightyear
Report Abuse
27/01/2012 08:42:00

Still I dont think you lot will get any silverware this season :)
Report Abuse
28/01/2012 12:46:00

Impeccable timing there niteworlok as the Rags go crashing out of another competition. LOL. Crisis in Stretford???
Report Abuse
28/01/2012 14:43:00

My comment was before the match - yeah we got beat, no crisis for us, the rot is at the Etihad
Report Abuse
28/01/2012 14:52:00

lol that De Gea is something special NW. losing pressure games, cracking under it. The doubts are setting in in Stretford.
Report Abuse
28/01/2012 14:55:00

Yeah I know it was...precisely why you should have kept tight lipped until you had something to shout about. Schoolboy error. Priceless!
Report Abuse
28/01/2012 15:03:00

It's funny too when you think about it, getting Kompany sent off did you no good, you're out of the FA Cup now. Ultimately all it really achieved was given your most hated rivals Liverpool a route to Wembley and sees you no closer to us in the league. LMFAO!
Report Abuse
28/01/2012 15:09:00

Hart for me is 1 of the best Gk's in the World right now & he'll only get better & better, I'm so happy he's English.

However its ironic how when we have howlers against us that benefit you its either a laughing matter or "they never happened", yet when the shoes on the other foot its the end of the World & every1 hates City...

Btw IF we had lost fairly last week I'd of had NO problems coming back & congratulating you for a great win, however... I admit the Kompany red card was a farce (& I've not yet seen the Pen that never was), but for City fans to be moaning about Mario's stamp or even missing the fact Lescott got away with a blatant & deliberate elbow to Kabouls jaw & still grabbing the win in a 6 pointer just sounds like nonsense to ALL other fans... I rate & respect Mancini very much I also like him as a person, but he knows his moaning about certain decisions is a smoke screen to deflect away from the players.

Yes City have had decisions go against U, however Spurs have GENUINELY been cheated by so called "officials" 10 points this season, then you take into consideration us not starting when every1 else did so lacking match fitness compared to the rest of the eague, then the Modric saga & the fact we had naff all CM or CB options for U & Utd (2 games we were at least capable of draws if not 1 win & 1 draw had we not had the injuries to core members or Modrics head being turned). I say all this coz DESPITE all that nonsense we've had to deal with we're still 3rd & should in ALL right be 1st or 2nd depending on your results also being correct.

So put all that into context City are hardly in the worst position in the World now are you ! Ffs

Even still, don't it make you feel disgusted & utterly robbed, when you've just been CHEATED ?
True Spurs Supporter
Report Abuse
28/01/2012 16:47:00

TSS, sorry mate but that rant is pathetic. No one is defending Mario, the problem is the way the FA apply their rules without consistency and transparency and just seem to make it up as they go along. Are you trying to tell us that when Spurs have decisions go against them that they are cheated but when it happens to City it's just decisions going against them? Seriously mate read back over what you just said.
Report Abuse
28/01/2012 18:52:00

I don't know why you'd engage with an apoplectic and paraletic drunk on a forum Dubz. This moron is still ranting, a full week after we pulled down Spurs pants and gave their bottoms a good spanking. I've said it on our forum pages, Spurs have been denied points by bad linesman decisions; we've been robbed by blatant refereeing bias.
Report Abuse
28/01/2012 19:36:00

rojo - school boy error my arse - I felt we should have won that match but for a stupid goalie error and Evra being crap at LB yet again..... BD - I dont even understand why Lindergaard wasnt the one for this match - he has more composure in his area and is a good keeper, hellfire, even Tomasz has more composure than De Gea at the moment....
Report Abuse
29/01/2012 11:01:00

I found it amazing that U*d spent that much on De Gea in the first place. I mean the policy of buying VDS so late in his career worked so well, why then would you scrap that policy and spend £20 million on a kid?
Report Abuse
29/01/2012 11:39:00

Yeah - should, but ********. Crumbling.
Report Abuse
29/01/2012 15:50:00


Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Manchester City Articles

Aguero & Toure Ahead Of Juventus (Tuesday November 24 2015)

Aguero Sets New Record (Monday November 23 2015)

Pellegrini On Liverpool Disaster (Sunday November 22 2015)

Stats: Manchester City v Liverpool (Saturday November 21 2015)

Man City v Liverpool - Team Line Ups (Saturday November 21 2015)

Vital Preview - Man City v Liverpool (Saturday November 21 2015)

Archived Manchester City Articles

List All VMC Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites

Vital Members League (view all)

League Results (view all)

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
1. Leicester City 13 8 4 1 +8 28
2. Man Utd 13 8 3 2 +10 27
3. Man City 13 8 2 3 +14 26
4. Arsenal 13 8 2 3 +12 26
5. Spurs 13 6 6 1 +13 24
6. West Ham 13 6 3 4 +4 21
7. Everton 13 5 5 3 +8 20

Manchester City Fixtures (view all)

Breaking League News

Baines given green light to return
» Everton : 25/11/2015 10:00:00
Howe: Gradel on course for February return
» AFC Bournemouth : 25/11/2015 09:07:00
Cherries, Stoke & Man Utd track Leeds midfielder
» AFC Bournemouth : 25/11/2015 08:57:00
Where The Goals Come From
» Spurs : 25/11/2015 08:40:01
Liverpool: The Weekly LFC News Update 15/16 #15
» Liverpool : 25/11/2015 08:29:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

CL - Juventus v Man City
Suggested By:  VMC Admin
City win 25%
Juventus win 75%
Draw 0%