UK time is: 23:00:47
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

The Manchester Midfield Debate

VMC's Lorna takes a look at the City and Stretford engine rooms in a head to head analysis of some of the key players tasked with the brief of securing a platform for silverware...


14. Javi García, Age 25 has a good sense of passing ability, is not particularly blessed with great pace, never a box-to-box midfielder, but what he does do well is put in the tackles and keep the pressure applied. He is very much suited to a holding midfield role and will cover the gaps while the full-backs move forward. Impressed in his debut performance at Stoke even though he did pick up a yellow card on his first game!

García will play an important role this season and will be part of an elite team of central midfielders. As each game for the Blues gets harder, with all the other teams wanting to take the game to The Champions, having García join the central midfield was a must especially after the tough Champions League Draw and in the wake of Nigel de Jong's departure.

17. Jack Rodwell, Age 21 has a good passing ability and is capable of fine cross field passes to Toure, Nasri and Silva. Likes to keep the ball moving and is good at holding in front of the defence.

Apart from a little 'blip' at the beginning of his City career he comes over as a confident, determined young player and one who is proud to be part of the reigning Champion's squad. In time he will prove to be a fantastic signing for the Blues.

8. Samir Nasri, Age 25 is quick, flexible and good with his feet. Has good control with the ball and suits the position of central or deep mid-field well. He primarily plays as an attacking midfielder and winger. Nasri is renowned for his technical ability, creativity, pace, and ability to read the game.

21. David Silva, Age 26 our attacking midfield talisman, excellent at passing and linking play, holds on to the ball, and is good at through balls and taking set pieces. Almost impossible to stop once in possession of the ball, he has skill, agility and ability to create space. Given the nickname of Merlin, gained through his wizardry of playing the ball and creating chances, he is a joy to watch and a valuable asset to the team. Real Madrid's standing ovation for him this week recognised his growing global appeal.

42. Yaya Touré, Age 29 plays primarily in the position of box-to-box midfielder, has enormous physical presence and is admired for combining speed, passing ability, power and technique. Unstoppable when he goes forward from midfield and has amazing skill striking the ball on the run. As the match progresses he can move from offensive to defensive positions. A force to be reckoned with and a massive danger to opposing teams.

18. Gareth Barry, Age 31

Barry has been sorely missed of late. Left footed, reliable and consistent (quite often viewed as the unsung hero of the Blues), makes short passes so well, excels when playing alongside David Silva and works well with Toure. Barry may not be the most dramatic player in City's squad but the role of defensive midfield is all important and Barry covers it so well. Barry will step up to the plate now he is back from injury and strengthen the midfield.

7. James Milner, Age 26

James Milner can play anywhere. Central midfield holding role, left or right, is strong in defence and makes some key passes, running effortlessly. Well known for being a training animal and doesn't always get the credit he deserves.

11. Scott Sinclair, Age 23

Our speedy new winger looks to have good dribbling skills and favours cutting inside. Not too good at holding on to the ball but he is a young player and will gain vast experience the more he plays with City's stellar squad.


The rag midfield has been bulked up in Taggart's bid to regain his crown and achieve his ambition of 20 Premier League wins.

26. Shinji Kagawa, Age 23 was introduced and made his mark from day one with a style that links defence with attack. He is fast and full of energy. A player who wants the ball to be passed into him up front and direct, he likes time with the ball keeping busy. This is a style that the Blues are going to have to keep an eye on when The Citizens and rags lock horns in December. Is Kagawa a match for David Silva?...maybe!

Silva will no doubt be well aware of how Kagawa plays and no doubt many Blues will have observed this also. The hype surrounding Rooney and Van Persie was massive but without a good midfield, this alliance would not be so imposing. However, Kagawa has arrived as a chance maker and taker.

23. Tom Cleverley, Age 23 is in the position of central attacking midfielder for the rags, again another creator, he puts in a good performance and clearly loves what he is doing, but can be a little too eager in his efforts to score. Determination is good but perceptiveness has to come with it.

8. Anderson, Age 24 box-to-box midfielder, good eye for the ball, has adept ability when it comes to tackles, is tireless, strong and determined. Not altogether a fantastic player but one to watch nonetheless. He has himself admitted that United needed to buck up in order to win silverware this season.

22. Paul Scholes, Age 37 Pretty much good at everything he does; passing, scoring with his left foot, right foot, his head. Has a bit of a record of yellow cards and also for being sent off of course. Scholes himself had said after his retirement that the tackles were to 'get back at players who had fouled him earlier in the game.' The reputation surrounding his tackles led to him often being unnecessarily booked.

16. Michael Carrick, Age 31

Primarily a central midfielder, Carrick has quite distinctive features including his inventive passing of the ball along with his crossing abilities. He does however have a historic ankle injury which periodically rears its head and there are stong possibilities that this will be a 'touch and go' season for him.

11. Ryan Giggs, Age 38

Despite his well known abilities, he remains not one for diving into tackles, still tends to lack concentration and tends to foul a lot. Similarly to Milner, despite turning 39 this November, he continues to run and run. But as with Scholes and Carrick, the clock is ticking.

18. Ashley Young, Age 27

Young has many attacking strengths and like Giggs, he likes to play the ball into the air. Appears to be fouled a lot and is not too hot on the tackling side of the game, neither does he like headers.

17. Nani, Age 25

Remains an erratic attacking threat for the rags. He has many strengths, has a passion for shooting from distance and likes to pass and run. This is an important season for him.

- So there we have it across the great divide.

This campaign could yet develop into another battle to end all battles in Manchester. Fergie is determined to regain his crown and Mancio is determined to hold on to it. Midfield is where the fight will be won and lost.

The strikers at both clubs are awesome but when it comes to midfield which team would you put your money on?

all times East Manchester

Su 23 Sep 16h00 Arsenal, The Etihad, PL
Tu 25 Sep 19h45 Aston Villa, The Etihad, LC3
Sa 29 Sep 15h00 Fulham, Craven Cottage, PL
We 03 Oct 19h45 Borussia Dortmund, The Etihad, PL
Sa 06 Oct 12h45 Sunderland, The Etihad, PL
Sa 20 Oct 15h00 West Brom, The Hawthorns, PL
We 24 Oct 19h45 Ajax, Amsterdam Arena, CL
Sa 27 Oct 17h30 Swansea City, The Etihad, PL

Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

The journalist

Writer: Lorna Silva Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Friday September 21 2012

Time: 6:37AM

Your Comments (oldest first)

Change to most recent first
Not sure whats to debate Yaya, Silva, Nasri new boys Garcia and Sinclair and solid fill ins Milner and Barry... its shocking though how the purple nosed one gets the performances he does from his set of knackers yarders and newer guff.
Report Abuse
21/09/2012 07:46:00

Central midfield is City's hands down. It's out wide where they are particularly strong. That can be put down to the two managers different styles, as Mancini unlike Sir ***** Can doesn't like to use orthodox wingers. Overall I'd say City have the edge as central midfield is the most important area, win the battle in the centre of the park and you can dictate the pace of the game.
Report Abuse
21/09/2012 07:51:00

Giggsy's aerobics videos will only keep himself and Scholesy going for a few months more. If they are both knacked by Christmas, they're in trouble.
Johnny Baguette
Report Abuse
21/09/2012 09:28:00

Oh, but the Glazers will lavish money on an entire new midfield if that happens JB! Happily take our midfield over any other in the League, ta very much. Think only Arsenal and Chelsea even come close when it comes to talent and strength in depth.
Report Abuse
21/09/2012 10:36:00

We still don't have a central midfielder who can pull the strings like Xabi Alonso did against us. Mancini likes his fierce and tough tackling midfielders but I still believe we lack the sort of player who could spray 80 yard accurate passes. Veratti who were we interested in but PSG signed looks like he could be the next great one in that mold.
Report Abuse
21/09/2012 19:21:00


Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Manchester City Articles

Liverpool v City (Team News) (Saturday February 28 2015)

The Ped Report.. City 1-2 Barcelona (Wednesday February 25 2015)

Praise For Suarez But Confidence Remains (Wednesday February 25 2015)

Hart - We'll Give It Everything (Wednesday February 25 2015)

Pellegrini Post Barcelona Defeat (Wednesday February 25 2015)

Stats: Manchester City v Barcelona (Tuesday February 24 2015)

Archived Manchester City Articles

List All VMC Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites

Vital Members League (view all)

1. Skoorb 260
2. Buzz Lightyear 255
3. Johnny Baguette 231
4. fifthcolumnblue 147
5. kennyclementstache 126
6. rojo2010 114
7. Bluedub 114
8. citizhun 87
9. CITYBOY1000 70
10. johnkelv 57

League Results (view all)

Latest Results
Man City 5 - 0 Newcastle
Stoke 1 - 4 Man City
Man City 1 - 1 Hull City
Chelsea 1 - 1 Man City
Man City 0 - 2 Arsenal
Everton 1 - 1 Man City

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
1. Chelsea 26 18 6 2 +34 60
2. Man City 26 16 7 3 +31 55
3. Man Utd 27 14 8 5 +20 50
4. Arsenal 26 14 6 6 +20 48
5. Southampton 27 14 4 9 +18 46
6. Liverpool 26 13 6 7 +9 45
7. Spurs 26 13 5 8 +5 44

Breaking League News

Monk: 'They Weren't Penalties At All'
» Swansea : 28/02/2015 20:56:00
Dyche: There Wasn't Anything Between The 2 Sides
» Swansea : 28/02/2015 20:49:00
40 Points, Up to 8th In The League!
» Swansea : 28/02/2015 18:48:00
Liverpool: Lawro Predicts 2014-15 - Man City (H)
» Liverpool : 28/02/2015 18:43:00
AUDIO - Sam`s Disappointment
» West Ham : 28/02/2015 17:58:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Liverpool v City
Suggested By:  VMC Admin
City win 44%
Liverpool win 42%
Draw 14%