UK time is: 23:57:17
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

Ped Into Europe Report City 0-2 FC Barcelona

Once again the Manchester rain welcomed our esteemed visitors from the aristocratic football kingdom of Catalonia. A team resplendent in its construction bearing an array of world class stars brought its proposition to the Etihad for what would probably be its sternest examination of the season so far.

Despite sitting atop its own domestic league, facing the ever improving Manchester City, Barcelona knew that the relatively new kids on the Champions League block would not lie down and roll over like just about every other opponent in the BBVA Primera Liga. They came with their expected game plan and found that Manuel Pellegrini's men had the measure of them for much of this encounter.

Fielding their best available eleven, they came, they played and they just about conquered a Manchester City side which stood toe to toe with them in the centre of the ring, but not without an element of controversy.

Both teams set off pressing as high up the field as they could, keen not to let their opponents play on the lack of consistency offered by the respective back fours. For some reason, despite Lescott's excellent turn-back-the-clock performance last Saturday, he was relegated to the bench in favour of Demichelis who for me was always going to be a risk today in terms of his lack of pace against an attack that not only has pace in abundance but also contains one of the world's most gifted footballers, one Lionel Messi.

Pellegrini also positioned Kolarov ahead of Clichy on the left to counteract the often free running Dani Alves, a ploy that worked until other factors, especially the sending-off of Demichelis and the subsequent sacrifice of Kolarov for Lescott, took their toll. Kolarov's inclusion meant no place in the starting line-up for neither the suspended Milner nor Nasri and Jovetic was unlucky too to be making way for "the system". But it was a system that was working. In the first half despite suffering periods without the ball, City dug in deep as Xavi gave a superb display of penetrative midfield football. But much of his work came to nothing as Fernandinho and Kompany closed off the doors that Xavi generally opens with the precision of a Swiss locksmith.

Yaya Toure was City's version and he pressed his team forward bringing Silva and Navas into play as often as possible, but just as often the final ball into Negredo was predictable with Busquets reading the play and stopping it by hook or by crook. Generally the latter.

It was astonishing how frequently he and Mascherano twisted the laws of the beautiful game and were not found guilty by the Swedish referee. Yet the first time that a City player, the inevitable Kolarov weighed in with something heavy, Mr Erikssen went immediately to his pocket and produced a yellow card. Negredo soon followed for practically nothing.

Both teams effectively cancelled each other out in the first half, leaving the field with honours even and nothing on the scoreboard. This gave the Blues fans a lift because against a less resilient opposition, Barcelona would have had the game in the bag by half time, but City had them rattled. They were not getting their customary own and they did not like it. Even the majestic Messi was hitting the grass after gossamer-thin contact in his bid to keep his team on the ball and time and again Erikssen bought into it. This kept undue pressure on City, but Kompany was king with a masterful performance of central defending, ensuring that Hart, guarding the pipes tonight had almost nothing to do. Xavi and Iniesta tried to keep their foot on the gas, but when you have two sides with time targets for ball-recovery when they lose it, this was certainly a hard fought match for both teams.

As the second half began, City set about it with a purpose and once again Barca were stunned and once again they didn't like it. Fernandinho and Yaya began to dictate in midfield as they got to grips with Xavi and Iniesta, leaving Busquets as the main thread of resistence. Then they got not a slice but a dollop of luck from the referee. Busquets weighed in Navas in a way that would have earned a City player a yellow card. Erikssen said "No" and allowed play to continue. The ball found its way to Messi close to the edge of the box with Demichelis in close attendance. Demichelis' poor attempt at a tackle resulted in a penalty and him getting a red card. Messi stepped up, waited for Hart to signpost which way he would dive and then coolly slotted the ball a foot the other way.

I can never understand why a defender takes the risk of a red card in situations like this. With Messi having shaken him off and bearing down on goal, you would expect him to score. If he does you still have eleven men on the field. You foul him, you're gone and he scores anyway. The early photographs in the Spanish Sports daily, Marca, which generally favours Real Madrid, clearly showed that the initial contact was outside the penalty area and took delight in telling the world how lucky Barcelona were to get the award.

Down to ten men and losing 0-1 with thirty five minutes still to play, virtually every City fan in the Etihad would have taken that result as to reverse it at the Camp Nou would have given the Blues a chance, especially as Aguero might well have returned from injury by then. But Pellegrini couldn't run with only three defenders against a team that at last was starting to find space and threatening to punish his side, so Kolarov had to be hooked in favour of Lescott to give the defence a more solid look. But his removal opened the door for the hitherto unheralded Dani Alves to get a free run at Clichy, not the best defender in the world.

Things now started to happen down the Barcelona right with Alves having the space of a free range chicken and starting to fire crosses high and low into the box, as well as having the odd strike on goal. But City held tight, keeping tabs on Messi and even Neymar when he was introduced until the game had just about ended when a lapse in concentration by a tiring Blues outfit allowed Dani Alves one last chance and he took it, prodding the ball between Hart's legs to give Barcelona what I would suspect to be an unassailable 2-0 lead to take home for the second leg. Now City need to win at least 3-1 to get through to the last eight.

There were only seven chances in the whole match with Barca leading those four to three. Negredo almost got through twice but was unfortunate. Neither Silva nor Navas nor Toure nor Nasri could make anything count, so with Barca in the lead on the scoreboard it was never going to fall into City's favour.

Yes, the Pedmachine is disappointed that City lost 2-0, but I am proud of the way the team fought for each other. Football can be a cruel game and tonight City did not deserve to lose 2-0. They did not deserve to lose at all. Regular readers of the Ped Report know that I pull no punches in criticising City when it is due, but tonight I cannot say that. They put in a well-worked-out performance which was doing the job until the non-intervention of a poor referee gave Barcelona the key to the quarter-finals. To not have collared Busquets for the foul on Navas would have got a Premier League referee a weekend in the Championship or League One. That Erikssen will get away with his performance tonight is unforgiveable. That Busquets managed to escape the night without admonishment was simply incredible. That this combination resulted in a red card for Demichelis and a penalty conversion for Messi was bang out of order. Never again will I call a Premier League referee and I have today signed up as an official member of the Mark Clattenburg fan club. (Howard Webb was pushing it!).

The Redtop Quadruple now looks to have gone and City can get back to searching for domestic rather than international honours this season. But they can take with them the pride of Manchester for a hard fought performance against one of the world's best and greatest teams. Don't forget it is the same Redtops who carefully edited what Pellegrini had to say at the pre-match press conference, where he alluded to the fact that City are bigger than United (this season). The key words were carefully omitted to create the kind of headline that Pellegrini does not seek and that would have horrified him.

That said, whereas I believe he got his tactics right tonight, I do not believe that fielding Demichelis helped his case. You can get away for so long by reading the game and positioning yourself accordingly but as the famous Stretford Rio Ferdinand has been finding out for a few seasons now, in the end the pace of the game finds you out and that is precisely what happened to Demichelis tonight. For me Kompany and Lescott would have been the correct combination as this would have given the back line a more solid feel.

I would take my case to the Camp Nou in three weeks time and simply go for it. Other teams have done it in the Champions League and made it. For City it will be a difficult task but Pellegrini should have one trophy in the Etihad bag by then and hopefully his team will be buzzing from that. It is a fixture that heralds the start of four aways in five in March which includes visits to the Theatre of Shattered Dreams in Stretford as well as the Ashburton Grove Bottling Factory in North London. It could define the destination of the Champions League and Barclays Premier League trophies this season.

UPCOMING DATES FOR YOUR FILOFAX:
all times East Manchester GMT

Sa 22Feb 15h00 Stoke City, The Etihad, PL
Su 02Mar 14h00 Sunderland, Wembley, LCF
Sa 08/Su 09Mar Wigan Athletic, The Etihad, FACQF
We 12Mar 19h45 Barcelona, Nou Camp, CLR16
Sa 15Mar 12h45 Hull, KC Stadium PL
Sa 22Mar 15h00, Fulham, The Etihad, PL
Tu 25Mar 19h45 The Stretfords, the swamp, PL
Sa 29Mar 17h30, Arsenal, The Emirates, PL




Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!



Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

The journalist

Writer: Pedmachine Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Wednesday February 19 2014

Time: 1:22AM

Your Comments

Tough luck last night but to blame the ref is wrong. Navas was stupid in throwing himself to the floor when he wasn't tripped and the ref rightly didn't give a free. The rule stats "tripping or attempting to trip" not "contact"!

Regardless of where the first foul occurs if it continues into the box and the attacker is fouled again then its a penalty so he ref was right in both counts.

Thought with 10 men you did very well to contain Barca but the 2nd goal right at the death was the killer.

Suppose it's up to us now to hammer Munich and show the world that the PL isn't all hype!

Galway Gooner
Sorry Galway but what are you on about regarding the penalty? If he is fouled outside the box it's a free regardless if the momentum carried him into the box. The complaint about the Navas incident is that Barca were getting frees for that exact thing all night long but when a sky blue shirt does it then it's no foul?
Bluedub
Messi was dropping as though he had a deadly virus all night. Best player in the world?
pedmachine
No way would The Arsenal's Arsene Wenger agree with that assessment Galway. Never in a million and I cannot imagine any Gooner accepting it were they on the receiving end. From Block 121 I can assure you the ref was scattergun all night and took good care of Barca. Good luck at Munich. You'll do well to repeat our win there! They are a machine!
Johnny Baguette
Great to see you last night Ped! The trams home were philosophical in mood, frustrated and proud. Yet also identifying one or two areas for squad strengthening to take us where we want to be. Brilliant assessment as ever in your report. Let's take it all out on Stoke and Sunderland!
Johnny Baguette
Oh but for the purchase on one Monsieur Mangala in January! :/
fifthcolumnblue
Bluedub - you are incorrect there. The FIFA rules state that the ref should award a penalty if the initial foul took place outside the box but the foul play continued into the box. So the ref was right to award the penalty and the ref card.

Personally think that Navas dived looking for the free so I don't think it was a free for me. Barca may have gotten similar frees in their favour last night but that doesn't make Navas's play acceptable, he dived looking for the free and didn't get it and ended up costing his team.

But it could be worse, you could be playing Bayern!!!

Galway Gooner
Never heard anything more ridiculous in my life, suppose it is FIFA. The foul occurred outside, it should be a free, end of. My gripe is with consistency in regards Navas, it seems there was one rule for them and another for us.
Bluedub
Bluedub- refs do have the option of playing the advantage! Game was filled with a lot of niggly fouls and stop start type play. Maybe Navas would have got a free on another occasion but for me I think he dived.

Honestly don't think that the ref was against you last night, though Negredo was lucky to stay on the pitch, he committed several fouls and must have been close to a second yellow.

Galway Gooner
Yet he wasn't awarded any frees for Mascherano fouling him every time they challenged for the ball. How many cynical tackles to stop counter attacks did Barca make before anyone was booked? Alves in particular, with Busquets not far behind. Perhaps Barca are just better at diving than we are.
Bluedub
Blue - I sense your frustration and I know where you're coming from. Everybody talks about how great a team that Barca are but anytime we've played them I've found them to be a spiteful and cowardly team who throw themselves to the floor at the mere hint of contact and spend the game brandishing cards to the ref in an attempt to influence them. Would love it if you stuffed them over there.

Unfortunately on top of all their bad qualities they are also pretty handy at actually playing football!

Galway Gooner
bang ! goes the quadruple
Blue_Mel
I don't think the tackle on Navas was a foul, he threw himself on the floor so dramatically it would have made Busquets proud. but it wasn't a penalty https://scontent-a-fra.xx.fbcdn.net/hphotos-prn1/t1/397478_700441903348061_401366635_n.jpg
Humza_96
LOL @Galway Gooner. Arsenal can't talk about ref decisions against barca. the only reason you won 2-1 against them is because messi had a goal disallowed for no reason. We chelsea fans get screwed over the most by refs in Europe so we have a reason to be pi$$ed. Arsenal just get knocked out cos they're *****, no blame on any refs. 'A spiteful and cowardly team' you talking about arsenal or barca?
Humza_96
Humza I'm an Arsenal fan and I cant even remember that so called Messi goal - talk about obsessed!

I do remember RVP being sent off for taking a shot after the whistle blew in Barca however, wasn't lucky for us.

Chelsea may have had some bad decisions against them but I don't think that you lot, of all teams, can call bad luck in the CL - one of the luckiest winners ever! And yes I know that's one more win then we have.

Galway Gooner
feel sorry for city fans. but any team that has a realistic chance of beating barca has to deal with the refs first. only teams that stand no chance from the start like arsenal and united get a fair refereeing performance.
Humza_96
Mel, would that be the media's quadruple you're referring to? No one from City or connected to City ever claimed we would win the quadruple, it's just the media's way of building us up to knock us down, *****s that they are. All Pellegrini ever said is that we will try to win every competition we're involved in.
Bluedub
Humza - net spend of about 600m over the past decade, yeah the cards are really stacked against Chelsea.....
Galway Gooner
us spending 600M has nothing to do with refs screwing us over. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t78THn_7qns here's the messi goal. And as for the RVP sending off, yes it was harsh but it's his fault and technically was deserving of a yellow card. He did hear the whistle, anyone that believes he didn't knows very little about football. you can tell by the way he shot that he knew he was offside. Every ST does it but he unfortunately got penalised for it
Humza_96
we had luck in our CL win BUT none of it was help from refs. A referee never once helped us. People get annoyed if they lose because of a ref fkin up. When one team hits the post several times they say they were unlucky but there's no one to blame apart from themselves. for example in that CL match vs barcelona in 2009 when that BS ref cost chelsea the game by denying 4 clear penalties chelsea fans were annoyed because we lost cos of the fkin ref. if we had wasted chances and hit the post we'd be annoyed at our players inability to finish chances and say it was bad luck. But we wouldn't complain about barca and refs would we? We had footballing luck in our CL win. Barca have incorrect refeering decisions on their side. There's a big difference between the 2.
Humza_96
How's your quadruple getting on Blue_Mel? There's a name for fans like you who come to gloat about a result that has nothing to do with them - window lickers. Now go scrape your tongue
fifthcolumnblue
Glad you said that fifth for a minute there I thought I was on the wrong site, with a Gooner and Chelsea fan having an argument!!!!as for last night we put up a great show, and held our own against the 'best' footballing side in our generation, but for a penalty I dont think they would have scored against 11 men, but as much as I hope we will win in Spain I can't see it but WE WILL SCORE and then who knows against a FULL strength City side......
cityman51
If we get the mighty atom back, and Pelle picks a team to go at 'em in the return leg who knows what may happen.
johnkelv
I'd say our chances are about as improbable as Arsenal's of overturning the deficit, but you never know in football. I suspect Platini has wet dreams over a money-spinning Barcelona/Bayern final, and it wouldn't surprise me if that came to pass.
fifthcolumnblue
Following two nights of similar circumstances/results etc, a review of the rules with these sending off's needs to happen. I have said it many a time that a red card and a penalty is too harsh a punishment.
paul_ownz
Hear Hear Paul_ownz, but I reckon the chances of that happening are slim, seeing as the footbaling powers-that-be are terribly afraid of change
fifthcolumnblue
Hence the shackles of FFP.
RobsonGreensleeves
Demichelis is a liability in your defence
Tiny T
@cityman... Chelsea fan having an argument? dont think soo... just came to state a FACT! Barcelona best team in a generation ? I hardly think so... you should have played them when Chelsea did..even Mourinho said they were a weak Barcelona .. it shows that despite your relative strength at the moment , you still have a way to go. the best of bad luck to you in your future matches lmao
Blue_Mel
 

Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Manchester City Articles

Players Respond To Newcastle Loss (Thursday October 30 2014)

Harsh Rodney Marsh (Thursday October 30 2014)

Pellegrini - Same Failures Cost Us (Thursday October 30 2014)

Silver Lining (Thursday October 30 2014)

Boss Hopeful On Duo (Thursday October 30 2014)

Yaya Recognised (Thursday October 30 2014)

Stats: Man City v Newcastle (Wednesday October 29 2014)

The Great Dane - City Are Bigger (Wednesday October 29 2014)

Team News: City v Newcastle United (Wednesday October 29 2014)

Archived Manchester City Articles

List All VMC Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

1. Johnny Baguette 211
2. Skoorb 177
3. fifthcolumnblue 123
4. OziMan 98
5. Bluedub 86
6. rojo2010 81
7. kennyclementstache 73
8. CITYBOY1000 68
9. PhillyBlueMoon 63
10. johnkelv 56

League Results (view all)

Latest Results
West Ham 2 - 1 Man City
Man City 4 - 1 Spurs
Aston Villa 0 - 2 Man City
Hull City 2 - 4 Man City
Man City 1 - 1 Chelsea
Arsenal 2 - 2 Man City

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
1. Chelsea 9 7 2 0 +15 23
2. Southampton 9 6 1 2 +15 19
3. Man City 9 5 2 2 +9 17
4. West Ham 9 5 1 3 +5 16
5. Arsenal 9 3 5 1 +4 14
6. Swansea 9 4 2 3 +3 14
7. Liverpool 9 4 2 3 +1 14

Breaking League News

Swansea Hopeful Sigurdsson & Ki Will Return
Swansea : 30/10/2014 20:52:00
Swansea City Have Fernandez Red Card Rescinded
Swansea : 30/10/2014 20:44:00
Irvine Expecting Tough Leicester Encounter
WBA : 30/10/2014 17:12:00
Varela Resumes Full Training
WBA : 30/10/2014 17:07:00
Koeman Delighted With Second Stoke Win
Southampton : 30/10/2014 16:55:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

The Stretfords Are Getting Cocky. Who Will Win On Sunday?
Suggested By:  Ivor Galactico
The rags 50%
The Champions 50%