UK time is: 08:38:25
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

Manchester City 2 - Hamburg SV 1

City Of Manchester Stadium

Thursday 16th April 2009, 7.45pm

Attendance: 47009

Courageous City Win Not Enough

Manchester City beat Hamburg in a breath taking UEFA Cup quarter-final second leg, but the 2-1 win was not enough to send City through.

It was Hamburg who opened the scoring after taking an early lead in the first half, Paolo Guerrero shooting through the legs of Vincent Kompany to beat Shay Given.

A dubious hand-ball decision put City back into the game as Elano equalised from the spot.

After the break Ecuador striker Felipe Caicedo gave City a deserved lead, firing city in front after switching feet and slotting home to send the crowd into a frenzy.

City kept pushing for the third goal but Richard Dunne stupidly picked up a second yellow card and captain calamity was sent off leaving his 10 tiring team mates to struggle for a goal.

Martin Jol's side managed to hold out as City pushed on for a late winner and despite losing the game, went through 4-3 on aggregate.

City started the game at an astonishing pace, chasing the 2-0 win needed to advance. The vivacious crowd cheered on the Blues in rapturous fashion and became even louder after Micah Richards came close to opening the scoring.

Played through by the rejuvenated Elano, Richards stumbled and his effort was easily gathered up by Hamburg keeper Frank Rost.

Manchester City pushed on for a goal but their shaky defence was caught out on the counter-attack and Paolo Guerrero gave City a mountain to climb with a 10th minute goal.

Influential midfielder Jonathan Pitroipa, got himself into space on the right and the defence didn't cut the ball out allowing Guerrero to punish the Blues, firing low through Vincent Kompany and past Given for a 1-0 lead.

The goal meant that City needed three goals to get to extra-time but five minutes after Hamburg went ahead, Elano gave the fans some hope his 15th minute equaliser.

Elano scored from the spot, tucking the ball away into the corner past Roth. Piotr Trochowski was adjudged to have handled the ball in the box although on replay looked rather harsh.

An intense and focused City side came close to taking the lead on the stroke of half-time after the spectacular Elano fired a thunderbolt free-kick against the crossbar.

Half-time: Manchester City 1 Hamburg SV 1

Five minutes into the second-half City reduced the mountain to a hill as they reduced the aggregate score line by another goal, Felipe Caicedo making it 2-1 to send the crowd into fits.

Stephen Ireland passed to the Ecuadorian who made no mistake after cleverly switching the ball onto his left foot and scoring a great goal to fire City into the lead.

The goal gave City belief as Hamburg crumbled under the intensity of the game.

Five minutes after Caicedo scored, the impressive Elano crashed the ball against the post from another well taken free-kick with the rebound going out of play for a corner.

Rost lost the ball and the ball fell to Caicedo who fired over from only a couple of feet out leaving the gaping goal mouth empty and Hamburg off the hook.

The Hamburg keeper made a mense for his previous mistake saving from Robinho's close-range volley after the Brazilian broke through Hamburg's hapless defence.

A couple of minutes later, the repeatedly offside Caicedo put the ball in the net after rounding the keeper only for his effort to be ruled out for offside as City pushed for the vital goal.

Manchester City's monumental struggle was made all the more difficult after Richard Dunne was shown red after two bookable offences.

The referee had no choice but to send the City captain off after numerous warnings and City, who were now dominating the game, slowed up their attacking threat as they struggled to find a winning goal.

Seven minutes from the final whistle, Given kept City in the game after stopping Ivica Olic's close-range shot.

Micah Richards spurned his second opportunity of the game after firing over, City's last clear chance to send the tie into extra-time.

Substitute Daniel Sturridge fired a speculative effort into the side-netting in the dying seconds and Martin Jol's side held on to advance into the semis where Bundesliga rivals Werder Bremen await them.

Full-time: Manchester City 2 Hamburg SV 1

Star Player

Elano- The Brazilian was back to his best playing an astonishing game, hitting the post, crossbar and the back of the net. His work rate was top class and he has gone a long way to proving his worth.

Share Your Thoughts

I'm absolutely gutted that we didn't manage to progress here. The boys, minus Richard Dunne, played a fantastic game and deserved to go through.

City dominated the game and Hamburg were overwhelmed by an inspired performance from the battling Blues.

Kompany was a welcome addition to the City midfield and we looked far stronger than in the reverse fixture. Elano was outstanding and his compatriot Robinho was also at the top of his game.

Unfortunately we couldn't force a winner but the fans should be proud of the team effort and the fans in attendance did the club proud.






Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!

The journalist

Writer: Lincolnsmariner Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Thursday April 16 2009

Time: 11:26PM

Your Comments

i wsa very proud of the players tonight and im not going to point my finger at any one of the players either as they all played a part in a sad sad night for city and in europe for another couple of seasons. although i would like to say a special word for elano who was immense ..did have an injury with him being taken off after being the star man ??
bluemooner_mcfc
i wsa very proud of the players tonight and im not going to point my finger at any one of the players either as they all played a part in a sad sad night for city and in europe for another couple of seasons. although i would like to say a special word for elano who was immense ..did have an injury with him being taken off after being the star man ??
bluemooner_mcfc
Elano was our best player. Hughes is not good enough to be our manager.
Sindbad
Elano was our best player. Hughes is not good enough to be our manager.
Sindbad
Great performance from the boys and I'm proud of all but one of them tonight.
MCFC_Goatboy
Great performance from the boys and I'm proud of all but one of them tonight.
MCFC_Goatboy
So 7th place or those summer signings are looking like summer 2010 signings?
los_angeles_villan
So 7th place or those summer signings are looking like summer 2010 signings?
los_angeles_villan
Another excellent report 8thsin, 7th is not a reality now, we would have to win all the matches and there are some tough ones to come. I see there are some jokers who gave their votes to Richard Dunne as MOM, they must be from Hamburg.
Buzz Lightyear
Another excellent report 8thsin, 7th is not a reality now, we would have to win all the matches and there are some tough ones to come. I see there are some jokers who gave their votes to Richard Dunne as MOM, they must be from Hamburg.
Buzz Lightyear
Top report, eighth. A terrific effort last night. Time to maintain that level of belief in every game.
Johnny Baguette
Top report, eighth. A terrific effort last night. Time to maintain that level of belief in every game.
Johnny Baguette
Not wanting to be negative after such a passionate performance, but where's that passion been all season? It's one thing playing out of your skin in a European Quarter final, but if they'd shown the same desire throughout the season we'd be top 6 already. The benchmark has been set, and if nothing else we now know what they're capable of. At Blackburn Hughes squeezed that desire out of less talented players week in week out, lets hope he can do the same for us now!
BitterBlue
Not wanting to be negative after such a passionate performance, but where's that passion been all season? It's one thing playing out of your skin in a European Quarter final, but if they'd shown the same desire throughout the season we'd be top 6 already. The benchmark has been set, and if nothing else we now know what they're capable of. At Blackburn Hughes squeezed that desire out of less talented players week in week out, lets hope he can do the same for us now!
BitterBlue
I'm going to be very honest here... Yes the players put in a very good effort but... was that because they are fighters or is it quite simply because they were being watched by the chairman?
mcfcthriller
I'm going to be very honest here... Yes the players put in a very good effort but... was that because they are fighters or is it quite simply because they were being watched by the chairman?
mcfcthriller
If your a fighter... you play out of your skin every game because you want to be successful and have a desire to win... Not good enough having a team show up when the chairmans in town!
mcfcthriller
If your a fighter... you play out of your skin every game because you want to be successful and have a desire to win... Not good enough having a team show up when the chairmans in town!
mcfcthriller
We need a manager that will make the players fight to win every game... putting their heart and soul into it!
mcfcthriller
We need a manager that will make the players fight to win every game... putting their heart and soul into it!
mcfcthriller
Watched the replay on TV this morning - great fighting display. Why do we not show that spirit in every game?
Thaibluefan
Watched the replay on TV this morning - great fighting display. Why do we not show that spirit in every game?
Thaibluefan
Maybe because the chairman was watching???
mcfcthriller
Maybe because the chairman was watching???
mcfcthriller
I have no idea where the spirit came from but that is what is required every single week, especially in away games. I could hardly fault City's performance and now we must pin our hopes on an elusive 7th spot to qualify next season...
eighthsin
I have no idea where the spirit came from but that is what is required every single week, especially in away games. I could hardly fault City's performance and now we must pin our hopes on an elusive 7th spot to qualify next season...
eighthsin
Its not really a mystery is it, in buying the club when they did your owners screwed you over. Basically every player thats not robinho has been on borrowed time since the beginning, all year theyve been talking up who they are going to buy - in essence telling the current players they are not good enough. If that doesnt sap your belief/morale/"love for the shirt" I dont know what will. Hence inconsistency (something which, as a spurs fan I know plenty about). That said, as city fans youd take any games like this Euro one which are good after how you were a couple of years back, surely?
Joshtottenham
Its not really a mystery is it, in buying the club when they did your owners screwed you over. Basically every player thats not robinho has been on borrowed time since the beginning, all year theyve been talking up who they are going to buy - in essence telling the current players they are not good enough. If that doesnt sap your belief/morale/"love for the shirt" I dont know what will. Hence inconsistency (something which, as a spurs fan I know plenty about). That said, as city fans youd take any games like this Euro one which are good after how you were a couple of years back, surely?
Joshtottenham
khaldoon was the inspiration. no one else.
enzo city
khaldoon was the inspiration. no one else.
enzo city
We always played out of our skins whenever Peter Swales or Frannie Lee were watching so who knows!
kennyclementstache
We always played out of our skins whenever Peter Swales or Frannie Lee were watching so who knows!
kennyclementstache
 

Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

League Results (view all)

Latest Results
Man City 0 - 1 Stoke
Man City 3 - 1 Liverpool
Newcastle 0 - 2 Man City

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
1. Chelsea 3 3 0 0 7 9
2. Swansea 3 3 0 0 5 9
3. Aston Villa 3 2 1 0 2 7
4. Man City 3 2 0 1 3 6
5. Liverpool 3 2 0 1 2 6
6. Spurs 3 2 0 1 2 6
7. Arsenal 3 1 2 0 1 5

Breaking League News

Liverpool: Rodgers Delighted To Recapture Old Form
Liverpool : 01/09/2014 08:37:00
Cork Youngster Signs
Hull City : 01/09/2014 08:30:00
Aston Villa 2-1 Hull
Hull City : 01/09/2014 08:29:00
Van Ginkel Off to Milan
Chelsea : 01/09/2014 07:46:00
Remy - Pleased as Punch!
Chelsea : 01/09/2014 07:35:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Who Will Be City's Top Scorer This Season?
Suggested By:  Derek Parlane
Negredo 10%
Jovetic 41%
Aguero 41%
Dzeko 8%