Vital Football

Latest Manchester City News

Honeymoon Period Ends In Horrific Fashion

2 - 0

Goodison Park

17.30 Gmt

Attendance: 37,378


Manchester City did little to emphasise their stranglehold on the top four contingency with a lacklustre display witnessed at Everton's Goodison Park.

The Merseyside outfit contributed to a dismal day for Mancini's men with a battling, determined and aesthetically pleasing display which made them comfortable winners.

Goals from Piennar and Saha guided Everton to a phenomenal win and display that questions their substandard league position. Most notably for the away side, was the lack of performance and discipline again from record, marquee signing Robinho. After replacing the injury-prone Santa Cruz, Robinho was then removed himself, a lack of acknowledgment to both players and staff proved pivotal as he marched down the tunnel unaided.

Robinho wasn't the only non-performer for the Citizens, every area of the field was easily penetrated by Everton. Futile resistance from City, especially in a non-existent first half, brought back distant and discouraging memories from the display at Tottenham's White Hart Lane.

Title talk gathered around Eastlands after an emphatic 4-1 Monday night victory against Blackburn. However, after tonight's defeat, a top four position will again be seen as a remarkable achievement. The inconsistency of every Premier League side has given a number of teams hope to break into the top four, and with the power spending of the Blues, the expectations have been heavily placed.

The recent acquisition of Mancini has drastically improved us and has brought about a tremendous 100% return. Despite this, the well documented nature of his ability as a manager wouldn`t be greatly tested until today, with his first matches against weaker opposition. The cool tactician that Mancini has portrayed himself as disappeared on several occasions with outbursts of fury at his faltering side. Contrastingly, David Moyes hands on approach brought him great delight as his side picked off City with ease. The victory can again see Everton push towards a Europa League position. An achievement that would be considered on par as Manchester City making the top four.

In injury depleted side with little budget, Everton have often struggled this season. The team spirit instilled by Moyes though has left Everton fans witness a remarkable turnaround and fight back over recent weeks. Today's win saw Everton ecstatic and City exhausted.

After encouraging signs early on Manchester City wilted under constant Everton pressing. The harrying and destructive nature of Everton posed major problems for Mancini's men, dwelling on the ball too often and gifting possession to the home side.

As the half progressed signs of encouragement for the City faithful were decreasing. Lacklustre and lethargic displays have been uncommon under the new boss, however, today provided a greater test than expected. In possession we were bedraggled, out of it we were hopeless.

Both goals came from a terrific spell of football by Everton as the first half neared a close. Little comparison could be given to the referee and his official with two questionable decisions leading to Everton's goals.

Firstly, Pablo Zabaleta was deemed the offender on Saha, the striker tumbled on the edge of the box. A harsh decision, forgotten by terrible efforts in the City wall. As the wall broke, Piennar guided his free-kick into the bottom corner. Cue scenes of displeasure from both the manager and supports.

Saha then netted himself from the penalty spot. A decision that brought mass confusion from the City defence and even the reciprocate himself. Richards was penalised for a tug on Saha's shirt, notably the decision was given by the linesman after initial contact started outside the box.

With the groans exaggerated and growing we were left with little to cheer. On occasion we entered the Everton half, we did little to merit the unlikely comeback. Unfortunately instead of a courageous comeback, City were lucky to escape with only a 2-0 punishment. Both the superb Fellaini and the battling Cahill witnessed there headed efforts hit the frame of the opposition goal.

The final whistle was greeted with deafening cheers from the home fans. City were left shell-shocked.

An insufficient display compounded more misery on a disappointing score line. A defiant response is needed from City and no greater task beholds us than a Manchester derby this Tuesday.

Star Player

A poor display recorded no star player.

Player Ratings


Would have been disappointed with his efforts for the first goal. Great save from Fellaini and will be furious with his defence.


Rash tackles and poor on the ball didn't help his cause.


Could consider himself a little unfortunate with the penalty decision. Other than that much needed room for improvement. Didn't dominate aerially or on the floor.


City's best defender in a shocking display. Nonchalant at times and this creates panic at the back.


Poorest performance since his return to the team. Had little influence going forward but was sturdy enough defensively.

De Jong-5

Poorest performance in a City shirt. The mind boggles over his decision to split from the wall. Could have little influence with a shocking all-round team display.


One of the poorest players on what was a vitally important fixture for him. Instrumental in recent weeks, Barry looked a poor shadow of himself.


Tireless. Had little opportunity to match his season performances.


Gave the ball away far too much. Looked pathetic in a 50-50 tackle and did little to create. Hobbled off.

Santa Cruz

Injured-4 minutes.


Ran around even when unfit. No chances were created for Tevez as he failed to get on the scoresheet for the first time since Spurs in the League.


Inadequate. Maybe his last performance in a City shirt where he won't be remembered to kindly.


Ran around like a headless chicken and did nothing to influence a goal.


In a brief display probably our best outfield player. Ran with real effect and created problems. Should have started.

Date:Saturday January 16 2010
Time: 9:01PM


We've still got some very winnable games on the way and fortunatley no one took advantage today and also with Liverpool and Spurs playing each other midweek, at least one will drop points
16/01/2010 21:35:00
Shockingly bad. Everybody but Tevez just quit. Never expected to see that.
17/01/2010 02:26:00
Sorry but as a Pompey fan stuck money on you lot to win the league and the jinx hit straight away sums the f˙cking year up
Super Bock 1898
17/01/2010 03:10:00
Super Bock - you have more faith than i do mate, have you never heard of 'Typical City?'. Me thinks this is just a blip in a long, long road.
17/01/2010 03:45:00
Hope you stuff Fergie's red 'uns on Tuesday, I really do. Best of luck for that one.
17/01/2010 05:46:00
Ah, I watched the game and you lot were poor, but Everton were magnificent!!
17/01/2010 06:46:00
Bluedub I hate to say I told u so. Too many big heads im afraid...
17/01/2010 08:23:00
Everton are a solid team, you have only beaten the lesser sides
Tiny T
17/01/2010 09:52:00
Honeymoon Period?, why...? Cause you beat stoke,Wolves and Blackburn?
17/01/2010 11:09:00
nobody ever said that everton are a 'lesser side' tiny t,i also wouldnt call arsenal and chelsea lesser sides.
17/01/2010 12:15:00
Page 1/2
  1. 1
  2. 2

Login to post a comment

Site Journalists

Editor email
Johnny Baguette
no email
no email
no email

Current Poll (see more polls)

When Joe Hart leaves City, for good in the summer where will he go?
Suggested By: Tudor
Another Premier League team54%
Lower league English side2%
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites
The Vital Football Members League
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
Vital Football Comment

Recent Manchester City Results (view all)

Manchester City Fixtures (view all)

Vital Members League Table

1.Johnny Baguette363
3.Buzz Lightyear187
5.Colin Is The King163
Write for Vital Football