Vital Football

Latest Manchester City News

Cup Dream Over Again

3 - 1

Britannia Stadium

19.45 GMT

Attendance: 21,813


Manchester City threw away the chance to win there only trophy of the season after a devastating 3-1 defeat, in extra time, at the hands of Stoke City.

Another must-win game loomed and the time has come to be counted. After a last gasp winner destroyed our chances of League Cup success and the chance of winning the league extremely slim, the F.A Cup was our only chance of lifting a much needed trophy. A trophy we deserve for our long standing loyalty and passion for the club. After spending £200 million in two seasons the chance for success has never been greater.

However, nothing has altered. Another year without success and with the team slipping away in the league and facing tough fixtures the hope for a good season is fading fast.

Too many tactical decisions, bad performances and lack of stability around the club have seen us take one step back rather than forward at this optimistic time. The quality of football over recent weeks has been diabolical, lethargic and unsatisfying.

Since Stoke have moved into the promise land their type of football has been heavily criticised and sometimes rightly so. Despite this a lack of initiative and knowledge has again seen us come unstuck at the Britannia stadium.

Mancini started the fixture with a defensive set-up, 7 defensive minded players all getting a start. Despite this we started strongly, good fluent football accompanied with a will to win and desire that has left us in recent weeks. This was different, we looked settled, and we took the game to Stoke.

The greatest first half chances fell to City players, Ireland and most notably Bellamy. The fiery Welshman was involved in everything and after great work from Adebayor he looked set to score, however, a last ditch smothering from Sorenson proved our downfall. Similarly Ireland was put through by strong Togolese running from Adebayor, but again his fantastic assist didn't find a finish to match.

Half time was approaching and the side looked pleased, the forums were buzzing with positive comments and the City faithful were out singing the loud-mouthed Stoke.

Although our first half performance was admirable and left us on top, something changed dramatically in the second. The enthusiasm and impetus wasn't there anymore. A Lack of endeavor, guile and technical ability was desperately needed. We continued to press, but this time with the usual cautious approach.

Stoke hit us on the break. Offering very little, they conjured up a great chance that substitute Kitson duly converted.

Fortunately, as it has done so often, an opposition goal spurred us on. Less than two minutes after Kitson's goal Bellamy justifiably levelled.

Pandemonium in the stands was short lived. After a tremendous display, probably one of his brightest, Adebayor was dismissed for the use of his arm. Bellamy led the protests but the referee was placed in front of the decision and had the belief red was the correct call.

Tension and anxiety swept the Britannia. Stoke had opened the scoring but were clawed back immediately, Adebayor then saw red leaving the hosts in the better position.

Extra time loomed, both sides were settling for a 90 minute stalemate that offered similar controversy to the league fixture one week ago.

Suddenly Stoke were left pulsated and overjoyed, Shawcross converting again from a Delap line-out, this time it was allowed to stand. City began to push but had little to show. Advancing and looking for the equaliser City were caught again. Tuncay provided the inspiration and after neat foot-work he added the third leaving no way back for City.

Unfortunately this wasn't the dream ending we had all hoped for. A sense of injustice and disappointment was etched across the travelling faces. A trophy we had hoped for so much in came to a disastrous end.

Star Player

Kompany- Moved into Centre mid didn't alter Vk's performance or perception. He stuck to the task well and looked very comfortable on the ball.

Player Ratings


Started well and dealt with all Stoke had to offer. Could do very little for the first and third goals but will be very disappointed at his decision to come for the second.


Battled and defended well down the right touchline. Gave us something going forward.


Great to see him get his chance. Played very well and partnered Lescott fondly. Should have done better for the third.


Another good performance. Always strong defensively and calm on the ball.


Defended reasonably well. His crossing wasn't at his best and overall passing let him down.


Moved into Centre mid didn't alter Vk's performance or perception. He stuck to the task well and looked very comfortable on the ball.


Offered very little. Should have scored a fantastic opportunity to take the lead. Needs to get more involved.


Played very well in midfield and is becoming a firm favourite of mine again due to his commitment and effort. Never shirks a tackle.


I felt this was one of his better performances. Needs that cutting edge back but improved from the weekend.


Always a threat. Scored the equaliser and was involved in every attacking break. Sometimes tries to take on too much.


Was very pleased before he saw red. Great running, skill and awareness. Deserved a goal and several assists. Should know better than to raise his hands.


Provides a strong attacking threat down the right. Crossing needs to improve as usual.

Santa Cruz-4

Poor and not involved.


Why bring him on?

Date:Wednesday February 24 2010
Time: 11:12PM


i'm frustrated that we've lost Adebayor and had to play an extra 30 minutes for nothing
25/02/2010 00:26:00
feel sorry for Adebayor on the red card, it is about time referee's blew immediately for shirt pulling . . . if he hadn't of been having his shirt tugged off his back he wouldn't have raised his arms!!!!
25/02/2010 04:53:00
Let's be honest, Rooney battles with opponents like Ade did for the sending off week in week out. Football will soon become a non body contact sport.
Johnny Baguette
25/02/2010 08:31:00
No Ade for Chelsea! Yay!
25/02/2010 09:05:00
Just another case of shocking refereeing inconsistency. Something is the matter though, with the squad you've got the replay shouldn't have even been played, and it didn't quite go to plan. It'll be interesting to see what happens come seasons end.
25/02/2010 09:37:00
I've never been so unsuprised in my life.
25/02/2010 10:08:00
Love Barry's review.
25/02/2010 13:20:00
Page 1/1
  1. 1

Login to post a comment

Site Journalists

Editor email
Johnny Baguette
no email
no email
no email

Current Poll (see more polls)

When Joe Hart leaves City, for good in the summer where will he go?
Suggested By: Tudor
Another Premier League team54%
Lower league English side3%
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites
The Vital Football Members League
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
Vital Football Comment

Recent Manchester City Results (view all)

Manchester City Fixtures (view all)

Vital Members League Table

1.Johnny Baguette363
3.Buzz Lightyear186
5.Colin Is The King163
Write for Vital Football