Manchester City - Lightning Strikes Three Times
UK time is: 04:39:15
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

City 0 - United 1


12.45 GMT

Attendance: 47,019

Lightning Strikes Three Times

For lightning to strike twice is unbelievable, a landmark occasion, for it to occur three times, well that`s bizarre. Manchester City succumb to another injury time winner against the Old enemy for the third time this season, Paul Scholes heaped misery on the home fans and left Mancini`s men distraught after his late goal earned United a 1-0 away victory to continue their push for the Championship. In contrast City slipped up in their own push for Fourth with Spurs breathing down our necks.

Today`s Manchester Derby received growing amounts of attention and was billed as "The Biggest Manchester Derby" for 30 years. Our usual objective is to harm their hopes of any glory and to earn local pride. However, for ourselves, the season`s end is fast approaching and the opportunity to play in the Champions League couldn`t be greater. An added incentive of the fuelled "Carlos Tevez" war as well as the heart-breaking defeats we have endured this season could be rectified if we managed a Derby Day victory.

The odd panic, the occasional nerve and the rare anxious moment is understandable, but today we were a wreck. From start to finish, the horror of another defeat against the enemy loomed and the anxiety surrounding this, as well as the pressure of Champions League football next year looked evidently nerve-wracking. United were far from their flourishing best, a team unbelievably over-reliant on talisman Rooney, have found it too difficult recently to cope, hence their decision to play the injured star. Rooney`s effect on the game was minimal, the watching eye was observing his ankle closely and he rarely entered first gear, missing several key opportunities to put the visitors ahead.

Scoring 11 goals in two games we couldn`t have enterted the game in greater confidence, however, the lack of creativity could have never been more apparent. We were lacklustre, lethargic and disappointed far too often, the outstanding performers were defenders, illustrating where our priorities lay. The 90 minutes brought unwanted similarities to the Liverpool game, slow, agitated and tense. The occasion was never going to decide who finished fourth or who indeed wins the Championship, but we felt disappointed after expecting so much.

For the majority of the encounter, the battling was between the two managers, the tampering amongst their own teams was to counter attack their opponent rather than force the issue. After being treated to some tremendous Derby`s this year, we couldn`t have asked for more; the ultimate comeback`s, the gut-wrenching hammer blows, the forgotten man proving so pivotal and most importantly free-flowing admirable football. Today was different, despite the sun beating down and the crowd in terrific voice, very little could encourage the players. Nigel De Jong`s destructive power and harrying of the opponents earned great applause, but more was needed, he wanted support.

United had the best of the opportunities in the first half, Darren Fletcher came very close from his dipping shot and Giggs and Rooney missed fantastic opportunities from 8 yards. For ourselves, Bellamy would have been pleased he was facing the ageing Neville and created a brilliant opportunity only for the ball to miss everyone. Near misses and the odd shout was the best we had been given, a slight applause from both fans at half time, portrayed how much more we wanted.

The second half again failed to create much, Tevez was willing to do his usual running but failed in his objective to score. He wasn`t getting the chances and neither were City, the final ball lacked the zip, the final move as indecisive and all that was won was territorial possession. The managers twitched nervously, their subs were hardly game changing, cutting out the opponent was far too easy. The counter attack looked the best opportunity for both teams to edge out a close-fought win but neither could manager that decisive blow.

As the game was nearing a close, City were hoping to avenge all the hurt with a late goal themselves, Somehow, we failed to witness the net bulge with Vieira having a goal winning chance that was finally cleared after a small exchange of pin ball. A draw was probably the most likely outcome and a fair result. Nevertheless, after countless last minute goals United are always confident of a late winner themselves and they had just that. Paul Scholes, scored another against us as he strode unwatched into the area, a far cross fell perfectly for the midfielder who headed home past Given`s despairing dive.

This was nightmare stuff. Three times we have had a draw/injury time result only seconds away, but again switched off at a crucial period. United didn`t, we were punished, the groans were deafening, squirming in our seats hoping to wake up, it was over, we had blew it.

Star Player

Nigel De Jong- Rises to the big occasions. He was excellent, he harried, chased and darted everywhere. He was remarkable defending all over the place and a constant nuisance.

Player Ratings


Looked steady, but couldn't stop a well placed header.


Brilliant performance. Nedum, the boy blue, was fierce and resilient. He didn't give their attackers a sniff and thwarted several attacks.


Probably his best City performance. Strong, read the game very well and has played much better than expected recently.


Started the game very nervously, twisted and turned on several occasions, as well as slipping, VK found it quite tough.


Seen as a potential weak link Bridgey played well. He had the chance to win the game on two occasions and was unlucky, defended very well though.

De Jong-9

Rises to the big occasions. He was excellent, he harried, chased and darted everywhere. He was remarkable defending all over the place and a constant nuisance.


A steady performance. Sometimes gave the United midfield too much space, but he put his foot in when it counted.


After some tremendous performances, this was possibly one step too far. He found it difficult to beat Evra and his crossing was particularly poor.


Our bast attacking player. He didn't have the best service, but ran the line very well. Created 1 or 2 good chances but needed more support.


He ran and ran, but never came close to hitting his best performance. One close free-kick, but he was too deep and tried to do too much.


He wasn't the target man we needed today. He failed to produce his best performance and really put pressure on a shaky defence.


Had a great chance to score. Couldn't keep up defensively.


Our most effective sub, was hacked down as per usual.


Offered very little and didn't get involved.

The journalist

Writer: Yak Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Saturday April 17 2010

Time: 4:47PM

Your Comments (oldest first)

Change to most recent first
Just can't believe it, done again. Concentration up in the air again. Two interesting things though: 1) Ireland's reaction to the goal: I'm his biggest fan but his face told it all, didn't give a *****, arms up in the air. 2) Tevez took 2 painkillers right infront of where I was sat after only 5 minutes of the match. Definitely carrying a knock
Report Abuse
17/04/2010 17:02:00

That would explain a lot Scragg, as Tevez didn't seem his normal self today at all. It didn't click for us today, neither side really looked good for a win, but we switched off again and were punished.
Report Abuse
17/04/2010 17:06:00

I really thought this would be a cracker, but it turned out a dud. Really disappointed for City. At this point in time, the difference between United and City is that United win these types of matches and City don't. It's not talent. It's not coaching. It's character. You're just not quite there yet and Stephen Ireland is the epitomy of what is still missing. I really think he's a talented player, but its obvious that he's not willing to do the little things required to win at the highest level. Tough day. Hope you still make the CL.
Report Abuse
17/04/2010 17:18:00

you were the arichtects of your own downfall conceding possession so easily so late on! Thanks lads!
Report Abuse
17/04/2010 17:21:00

yer bottles gone and fourth spot with it its ours for the taking now
Report Abuse
17/04/2010 17:42:00

spudsrus, have you won at Chelsea then? cos we will be up for it when you lot come to Manchester..... then, if you get something now, then next week at the swamp and then our place, you will deserve 4th, until then shut it.....
Report Abuse
17/04/2010 17:50:00

It was a very disappointing day. But once again it demonstrates what being a top team is all about. You have to concentrate for 90 or 94 minutes. Our central defence was nowhere to be seen and I thought Given should have saved it. We will still finish fourth though
Report Abuse
17/04/2010 17:58:00

Spuds 2 CFC 0 at half time. Bad day for Chelsea to do an Arsenal (ie, roll over)!
Report Abuse
17/04/2010 18:29:00

Bad results all round. League title race: United winning vs Chelsea losing. Fourth race: Spurs winning vs City losing. A bad day, but not the last day! Bring on next week already.
Report Abuse
17/04/2010 19:15:00

United packed the midfield and their extra player worked - simples. With our best attacker having an off day and our midfiled overrun we just couldn't get the attack in order and ended up chasing the game. No great controversies, although I thought Gary Chuckle handballed in the area and I can't understand how Rooney wasn't booked at least once, but there you go, that's the advantage the rags still have - the refs are reluctant to penalise them. Draw would have been a fairer result (even according to a couple of rags I've spoken to), but that's life, and that's football. Think Steven Ireland will be sold in the summer, although SWP did quite well when he came on.
Report Abuse
17/04/2010 19:30:00

its going all the way to the wire, I think its going to come down to our visit to Eastlands
Report Abuse
17/04/2010 19:33:00

Certainly looks that way keef - at least it keeps things interesting eh?
Report Abuse
17/04/2010 19:50:00

well what a bad day for us and city! spurs to get 4th? united to win the league? this saturday made that possible
Report Abuse
17/04/2010 19:55:00

Your game with spurs will decide it. Everyone talked about spurs tough run in but yours is now looking the tougher of the two.
Report Abuse
17/04/2010 20:16:00

Couldn't have summed the match up better OAB Still major gutted . Can't knock Spuds they have achieved two great results it really could be down to the match at our place Ill take that if it decided it. Let the best team win
taggarts nose
Report Abuse
17/04/2010 20:20:00

GO was spot on in the VMC Preview. A tight game, City needed to fly at them (we didn't of course) and we've played to narrow at the back against them this season (that's how the ball was played in for the goal). Be interesting to hear what he has to say in his VMC post match reaction on Monday. Stay tuned.
Johnny Baguette
Report Abuse
17/04/2010 20:31:00

fifthcolumnblue - Spurs and City don't do it any other way do we? See you on May 5th! I hope I my hang over doesn't keep me from voting...
Report Abuse
17/04/2010 20:32:00

Its on boys, let the best team win!
Report Abuse
17/04/2010 21:03:00

It wouldn't have mattered whether it had been 0-0 or 0-1 because Spurs would still have gone into fourth and the likelihood would still be that we had to beat them.
Report Abuse
17/04/2010 21:50:00

It will be a Great match if it does go to the wire and its us vs you guys should be a great open game of football!!! and may the best team win IF it does come to it ofcourse we both like to do it the hard way;) best of luck guys.
only 1 spurs
Report Abuse
17/04/2010 22:09:00

HAHA you slimey blue feckers, there's only one decent side in Manchester and its clearly not you.
Report Abuse
17/04/2010 22:21:00

TergeHauge, I admire your dexterity in getting around Netnanny. Wait till your father finds out............
Report Abuse
17/04/2010 23:13:00

Yes may the best team win on the pitch without the usual top 3 referee whingeing.
Report Abuse
18/04/2010 04:46:00


Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

1. Skoorb 234
2. Buzz Lightyear 205
3. Tudor 178
4. Johnny Baguette 141
5. Bluedub 83
6. fifthcolumnblue 60
7. johnkelv 44
8. PhillyBlueMoon 29
9. citizhun 29
10. Colin Is The King 20

League Results (view all)

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
1. Leicester City 25 15 8 2 20 53
2. Spurs 25 13 9 3 26 48
3. Arsenal 25 14 6 5 17 48
4. Man City 25 14 5 6 21 47
5. Man Utd 25 11 8 6 10 41
6. West Ham 25 10 9 6 9 39
7. Southampton 25 10 7 8 9 37

Manchester City Fixtures (view all)

Breaking League News

Newcastle To Reveal Mbemba Diagnosis
Newcastle : 09/02/2016 22:14:01
Welcome To The Cheap Seats
Newcastle : 09/02/2016 21:27:00
United Prepare For A Second Pre-Season.
Newcastle : 09/02/2016 21:05:01
An Open Letter to Roman Abramovich
Chelsea : 09/02/2016 19:43:01
AUDIO: UWS Podcast 144 - Chelsea away
Man Utd : 09/02/2016 19:23:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

How many trophies will MCFC win this season?
Suggested By:  Tudor
Premier League 12%
Champions League 0%
League Cup 10%
FA Cup 5%
Two of the above 10%
Three of the above 0%
All four 21%
City will not win anything this season 42%