Vital Football

Latest Manchester City News

Dubious Penalty Gifts Birmingham A Point

2 - 2

St Andrews


Attendance: 24,379


Consecutive away trips to the Midlands and more points dropped.
A highly controversial penalty for Birmingham ensured City left St Andrews with a point for the second season running.

Craig Gardner dispatched the penalty - after Patrick Vieira was harshly penalised for a foul on substitute Kevin Phillips- , as City`s stranglehold on the top four narrows with a disappointing 2-2 draw.

Carlos Tevez and Aleskander Kolarov gave us the lead on two separate occasions, but a defensive mistake and dismal refereeing allowed Birmingham to battle back and claim their second draw against us this season.

Defeating the lesser teams and winning away from home were two problems usually associated with City, but after a devastating run of performances and results away from home, the problems looked to have faded.

However- after firmly looking in place to mount a title challenge- five points dropped in two consecutive games has allowed the chasing pack to edge closer and the leaders to gallop effortlessly into the distance.

St Andrews isn`t a place to usually run riot at with only Everton and the impressive Arsenal registering victories here. Nevertheless, after four minutes City`s initial worries would have faded.

Birmingham deservedly gained a point at Eastland`s earlier in the season with a defensive master class, so the first goal-if it arrived- was very important.

After Tevez and David Silva had linked up well, the Argentine hit man scored to continue his formidable scoring tally. The anxiety surrounding another Birmingham clean sheet was eradicated, a steeping that should have been built on.

Despite the early chance, City failed to settle - the pitch could have been blamed- but City`s passing and link up play was far from fluent. The passing was off-target, the communication non-existent.

We were to quickly realise how damaging our failure to pressurise was with Nikola Zigic scoring for the first time in eleven games. City`s defensive frailty and lack of leadership was evident as Zigic stretched unmarked to level the scoring.

After an extremely impressive return against Notts County, Micah Richards retained his place, but was unfortunately stretchered off in a terrible clash of heads with Nigel De Jong. Stitches and a half-time substitution were required for De Jong, hospital and severe concussion left Richards in a heap.

With one full back injured, it was great timing for another to make an impact. Kolarov- who is looking more destructive each game- had the chance to use his devastating left foot again. Kolarov`s reluctance to shoot is similar to Roberto Carlos`s, any chance you take aim, from 25 yards out he stood over the dead ball powerfully struck goal-wards with great reward.

Taking the lead for the second time was essential. City looked more comfortable, the passing was more direct and the chances were coming our way.

However, with only 15 minutes left, referee Kevin Friend, was exactly that to the home side with a contentious penalty decision awarded. In fine form, Gardner stepped up and levelled.

City`s lead disappeared and so did the three points.

Player Ratings


Nothing wrong, nothing outstanding.


Desperately unlucky to suffer a terrible injury.


Defending was reasonable his passing wasn't.


Always performs to a high standard.


Defending steadily improving and is becoming lethal going forward.

De Jong-6

Part of the battle field with Richards.


Non-existent in the Midlands again.


Did very little. He is excellent at working hard, but his technique and skill looks a considerable weakness when lining up with Silva.


Influenced the game.


Was our greatest threat going forward.


At times he looked to have entered his high gear, but for the most was lacking.

Kolo Toure-6

Will perhaps find himself on the bench a bit more, after such an impressive start to the season he's gone off the boil.


Very poor display. Although it wasn't a penalty it was unbelievably clumsy.

Date:Wednesday February 2 2011
Time: 10:27PM


I think it was a penalty and Vieira is absolutely gash, should have brought Zabaleta on to replace injured De Jong. Vieira's awfulness cost us but lets be honest it was an appalling performance and we have gone off the rails at the worst possible time of the season. No width means Dzeko is isolated as Tevez and Silva are in a world of their own, ignoring him.
02/02/2011 23:02:00
Why keep SWP if you are not going to use him, what it a simple case of just being a name on the squad list as a home grown player? Well written article OaB agree with your marks and the ref was too quick to award the penalty in my opinion
Buzz Lightyear
02/02/2011 23:08:00
Dubious penalty? You're kidding right???
03/02/2011 02:17:00
Back in serious contention for 4th. Come on Spurs!
03/02/2011 08:02:00
Reckon it was a penalty myself although Philips did go down easily. Don't know what Mancini is playing at, why play defensively when we haven't a defense?
03/02/2011 08:25:00
Those charming redskins just can't help themselves gloating eh famous? Part of the personality defect that attracts you to the bright shiny red thing in the first place. Oh well, living vicariously through the achievements of others and lording it over everyone else must give you quite a warm sense of satisfaction and help you gloss over your own personal deficiencies.
03/02/2011 08:40:00
Zbam, no... deadly serious
Buzz Lightyear
03/02/2011 09:45:00
All that money spent and you are not going to win anything!!! Amazing failure really!
03/02/2011 11:56:00
Who says we're not going to win anything troll? We're still in FA cup and I believe we're favourites for Europa League, are we not? The amount of trolls that come on here when we drop points and they call us bitter, amazing really!
03/02/2011 12:17:00
No trophies have been handed out this season yet have they troll? what a silly statement you have just made
03/02/2011 13:04:00
Page 1/2
  1. 1
  2. 2

Login to post a comment

Site Journalists

Editor email
Johnny Baguette
no email
no email
no email

Current Poll (see more polls)

When Joe Hart leaves City, for good in the summer where will he go?
Suggested By: Tudor
Another Premier League team65%
Lower league English side5%
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites
Vital Football Comment
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
Write for Vital Football

Recent Manchester City Results (view all)

Manchester City Fixtures (view all)

Vital Members League Table

1.Johnny Baguette363
3.Buzz Lightyear184
4.Colin Is The King163
The Vital Football Members League